Skip to content

GCRI · Systems Science and Modelling

Model intercomparison

No single model captures a complex system fully. Model intercomparison runs several models on the same experiment with the same inputs, so that their agreement and disagreement can be seen and explained. It is how climate, crop, hydrology and epidemic modelling communities learned what their results can and cannot support. This page sets out how intercomparisons are designed, what they reveal, and what evidence serves the institutions that rely on model ensembles.

01Register

Model intercomparison on the record.

02The question

Model intercomparison: how the risk develops.

Comparing models of the same system, and what disagreement tells you. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

Mechanism

Common protocols isolate differences

When models share inputs, scenarios and output formats, remaining differences point to model structure and parameters rather than set-up.

Mechanism

Spread shows structural uncertainty

The range of results across credible models is a measure of how much the answer depends on modelling choices.

Mechanism

Ensembles are not independent

Models share code, data and ideas, so an ensemble can agree for shared reasons and overstate confidence.

Mechanism

Evaluation against observations weighs models

Comparing models with observations shows which reproduce key processes, which can inform how ensemble results are interpreted.

03Geography

Hazards and exposure in North America.

Flood water, population density and daytime surface heat over North America, from NASA GIBS. Each layer carries its own date.

Imephu esebenzisanayo idinga i-JavaScript; uhlu lwezendlalelo nemithombo luphansi.

Izendlalelo 3

Hazards and exposure, for this page

Mayelana nalesi sendlalelo
Ubufakazi
Kubonwe (amafu ashiya izikhala)
Umthombo
VIIRS Global Flood Product (NASA LANCE)
Umhlinzeki
NASA LANCE
Ilayisensi
Idatha evulekile ye-NASA
Inguqulo
nsuku zonke; ukutholwa ngesathelayithi; amafu ashiya izikhala
Okusha kakhulu ngesikhathi sokwakha
2026-10-14
Ukucaca
igridi elinganiselwa ku-250 m
Ukungaqiniseki
Ukutholwa ngesathelayithi; amafu ashiya izikhala. I-raster yesathelayithi noma yemodeli njengoba umhlinzeki eyishicilela. Amafu, izikhala zomzila nephutha lokuthola kushiya izikhala nomsindo; amanani angizinkomba, hhayi izilinganiso endaweni.
Kufinyelelwe nge-
ukudluliswa kwedatha kwale sayithi, kusuka ku-gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Mayelana nalesi sendlalelo
Ubufakazi
Kulinganisiwe
Umthombo
Gridded Population of the World v4.11 (NASA SEDAC (CIESIN, Columbia University))
Umhlinzeki
NASA SEDAC (CIESIN, Columbia University)
Ilayisensi
CC BY 4.0
Inguqulo
null; isilinganiso esisekelwe ekubalweni kwabantu, akuguquki (2020)
Ukucaca
igridi elinganiselwa ku-1 km
Ukungaqiniseki
Isilinganiso esisekelwe ekubalweni kwabantu sabantu ngekhilomitha eyisikwele ngo-2020, esiboniswa njengesimo sokuchayeka; akusona isibalo sabantu abathintwe yinoma iyiphi ingozi.
Kufinyelelwe nge-
ukudluliswa kwedatha kwale sayithi, kusuka ku-gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Mayelana nalesi sendlalelo
Ubufakazi
Kubonwe (amafu ahlala njalo asashiya izikhala)
Umthombo
VIIRS NOAA-20 Level 3, 8-day (NASA LANCE)
Umhlinzeki
NASA LANCE
Ilayisensi
Idatha evulekile ye-NASA
Inguqulo
izinsuku ezi-8; inhlanganisela yesathelayithi yezinsuku ezi-8; amafu ahlala njalo asashiya izikhala
Okusha kakhulu ngesikhathi sokwakha
2026-09-14
Ukucaca
igridi elinganiselwa ku-1 km
Ukungaqiniseki
Izinga lokushisa kongaphezulu komhlabathi ngesathelayithi phakathi nezinsuku ezi-8 eziphela ngosuku oluboniswayo, inkomba yokuchayeka ekushiseni; akulona izinga lokushisa komoya, inkomba yokushisa noma isexwayiso sokushisa.
Kufinyelelwe nge-
ukudluliswa kwedatha kwale sayithi, kusuka ku-gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Mayelana nalesi sendlalelo
Ubufakazi
Kubonwe
Umthombo
VIIRS NOAA-20 corrected reflectance (NASA LANCE)
Umhlinzeki
NASA LANCE
Ilayisensi
Idatha evulekile ye-NASA
Inguqulo
daily; Satellite image
Okusha kakhulu ngesikhathi sokwakha
2026-10-14
Ukucaca
igridi elinganiselwa ku-250 m
Ukungaqiniseki
Satellite image. Satellite or model raster as the provider publishes it. Clouds, swath gaps and retrieval error leave gaps and noise; values are indicators, not measurements at a place.
Kufinyelelwe nge-
ukudluliswa kwedatha kwale sayithi, kusuka ku-gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Mayelana nalesi sendlalelo
Ubufakazi
Modelled (latest year GIBS publishes)
Umthombo
MODIS Terra and Aqua land cover (MCD12Q1) (NASA LP DAAC)
Umhlinzeki
NASA LP DAAC
Ilayisensi
Idatha evulekile ye-NASA
Inguqulo
yearly; Satellite classification; latest year GIBS publishes
Okusha kakhulu ngesikhathi sokwakha
2024-01-01
Ukucaca
igridi elinganiselwa ku-500 m
Ukungaqiniseki
Satellite land cover classes for the year shown, including croplands; a classification with known errors, not a farm register.
Kufinyelelwe nge-
ukudluliswa kwedatha kwale sayithi, kusuka ku-gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Mayelana nalesi sendlalelo
Ubufakazi
Kulinganisiwe
Umthombo
GPM IMERG (NASA GES DISC)
Umhlinzeki
NASA GES DISC
Ilayisensi
Idatha evulekile ye-NASA
Inguqulo
daily; Satellite estimate, near real time
Okusha kakhulu ngesikhathi sokwakha
2026-10-12
Ukucaca
igridi elinganiselwa ku-2 km
Ukungaqiniseki
Satellite estimate, near real time. Satellite or model raster as the provider publishes it. Clouds, swath gaps and retrieval error leave gaps and noise; values are indicators, not measurements at a place.
Kufinyelelwe nge-
ukudluliswa kwedatha kwale sayithi, kusuka ku-gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov

Okutholakala kwakamuva

NASA GIBS / EOSDIS · ASTER GDEM (METI, NASA) · Blue Marble (NASA) · © abanikele ku-OpenStreetMap (ODbL) · Natural Earth

Iyalayisha izithombe zakamuva ze-NASA.

Donsa ukuze unyakazise. U-Ctrl noma u-⌘ bese uskrola, ucindezele ngeminwe emibili noma izinkinobho ukuze usondeze; beka isikhombi ukuze ubone amanani aphansi kwaso; ukusetha kabusha kubuyisela esifundeni.

Hazards and exposure, framed on North America.Satellite and model products as NASA publishes them, each with its own date. They are indicators, not assessments of any place.

Data: NASA GIBS · ASTER GDEM · Blue Marble · © OpenStreetMap contributors · Natural Earth · NASA EONET · U.S. Geological Survey · NASA JPL OPERA DIST-ALERTSources and licences

  • We acknowledge the use of imagery provided by services from NASA’s Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), part of NASA’s Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS). Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • We acknowledge the use of imagery provided by services from NASA’s Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), part of NASA’s Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS). Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • VIIRS near-real-time products (flood, land surface temperature, snow cover, corrected reflectance), NASA LANCE; imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • Center for International Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN), Columbia University. 2018. Gridded Population of the World, Version 4 (GPWv4): Population Density, Revision 11. NASA Socioeconomic Data and Applications Center (SEDAC). Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). doi:10.7927/H49C6VHW. CC BY 4.0
  • MODIS land products (vegetation indices, gross primary production, land cover), NASA LP DAAC and LANCE; imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • GPM IMERG precipitation, NASA Precipitation Processing System; distributed by the NASA Goddard Earth Sciences Data and Information Services Center (GES DISC); imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • ASTER GDEM is a product of METI and NASA (ASTER Global Digital Elevation Model V003, NASA LP DAAC); imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). Cite as: NASA/METI/AIST/Japan Spacesystems and U.S./Japan ASTER Science Team (2019). ASTER Global Digital Elevation Model V003. doi:10.5067/ASTER/ASTGTM.003. NASA open data
  • Kwenziwe nge-Natural Earth. Idatha yamamephu yamahhala ye-vector ne-raster ku-naturalearthdata.com. Esizindeni somphakathi
  • © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), via NASA GIBS (coastlines, boundaries, roads and place names). Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). ODbL
  • Blue Marble, NASA Earth Observatory; imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • Umongo ephaseleni nasemephini oyisicaba: amagoda olwandle, imingcele, imigwaqo namagama ezindawo avela emaleyeni ereferensi e-NASA GIBS (idatha ye-OpenStreetMap, ODbL, © abafaki be-OpenStreetMap); izithombe ze-Blue Marble njengesisekelo ongasikhetha; umhlaba we-3D nokufundwa kokuphakama okuvela enkombeni yombala wokuphakama ye-ASTER GDEM (amakilasi e-5 m kuya ku-200 m, andiswe ukuze afundeke kahle). Imingcele idwetshwe njengoba ishicilelwe futhi ayisho sikhundla ngasiphi isifunda.
  • Imicimbi eqondene nesikhathi samanje: NASA Earth Observatory Natural Event Tracker (EONET); imicimbi iyisikhombisi kuphela futhi igcina izixhumanisi zomthombo wayo wokuqala.
  • Bukhoma: NASA EONET Imicimbi iyisikhombisi, akuyizixwayiso zesiphathimandla.
  • Bukhoma: U.S. Geological Survey Imicimbi iyisikhombisi, akuyizixwayiso zesiphathimandla.
  • Observed (EO): NASA JPL OPERA DIST-ALERT (contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2026). We acknowledge the use of imagery provided by services from NASA’s Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), part of NASA’s Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS).
  • NASA GIBS: Siyakwamukela ukusetshenziswa kwezithombe ezihlinzekwe yizinsiza ze-NASA Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), eziyingxenye ye-NASA Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS).
  • Isibikezelo sokugcwala komfula, izinsuku ezingu-30 ngobubanzi (GloFAS nge-Open-Meteo): Iqukethe ulwazi lwe-Copernicus Emergency Management Service olushintshiwe lwango-2026; akusona isexwayiso sezikhukhula.
  • Idatha yesimo sezulu ivela ku-Open-Meteo.com (https://open-meteo.com/), enelayisense ye-CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
  • Optional layers (11 sources in the layer list: live, forecast, observed and context) print their provider credit on the map and here when switched on; forecasts are model output and derived indices are estimates.

Izendlalelo nezinsuku

  • Amanzi esikhukhula, inhlanganisela yezinsuku ezi-3: VIIRS Global Flood Product, NASA LANCE · 14 Okt 2026
  • Population density, 2020: Population: CIESIN, Columbia University, Gridded Population of the World v4.11 (2018), NASA SEDAC, CC BY 4.0 · static
  • Land surface temperature, day, 8-day composite: VIIRS NOAA-20 Level 3, 8-day, NASA LANCE · 14 Sep 2026
  • Umbala weqiniso: VIIRS NOAA-20 corrected reflectance, NASA LANCE · 13 Okt 2026
  • Land cover type (IGBP), yearly: MODIS Terra and Aqua land cover (MCD12Q1), NASA LP DAAC · 2024
  • Izinga lemvula, isilinganiso sosuku: GPM IMERG, NASA GES DISC · 12 Okt 2026

04Across the domains

Intercomparison is how each domain learns where its models disagree.

05Monitor

Coupled model runner.

The screen a team would use to follow this subject: its measures, states and decisions. Names are examples and values are illustrative.

Coupled model runner

Model intercomparison · Coupled model A · Scenario set 3

Ensemble runningGCRI · Systems Science and Modelling

Model coupling graph

nodes: models · edges: exchanged variables

Coupled components

Isayensi yamanzi1 dayrunoffYes
Power system1 hdemand, outagesYes
Umnotho1 quarteroutput, pricesPartial
Inani labantu1 yearexposureYes

Ensemble output

Coupled model runner: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Model intercomparison.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.
06Izinkomba

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

IndicatorUnitCadenceSource typeLabel
Models participating in an intercomparisoncountper roundIntercomparison recordsREPORTED
Ensemble spreadrange or standard deviation across modelsper experimentIntercomparison outputsMODELLED
Agreement on sign of changepercent of modelsper experimentIntercomparison outputsMODELLED
Skill against observationserror metric by modelper evaluationModel evaluationESTIMATED
Shared code lineage between modelscount of related model familiesper assessmentModel genealogy studiesESTIMATED
Outputs published in standard formatspercent of outputsper roundArchive metadataOBSERVED
07Twin and cascade simulator

Treat model intercomparison as a system. Run the cascade.

Assembled from the Nexus Standards area profile Compound and cascading hazard standards: the hazards it names, the systems and sectors that carry the loss, the controls that dampen it and the data that observe it. Choose the components, pick an initiating hazard and step through the cascade. The Map view places the run on an example geography with open data. Every coupling weight is a stated assumption you can change. A teaching model, not a forecast, an assessment or a certification. To model a place of your own choosing, open the full System Builder.

Izingozi

Controls

  • NS-0 Umthethosisekelo nezimiso
  • NS-3 Ama-UNI amarekhodi obungozi (uhlelo lolimi, ukuqhathanisa nezinhlelo ezindala, igunya lokwabela)
  • NS-9 Ama-UNI omongo (ukufakwa, izibonelo, izibonelo zohlelo)
  • NS-11 Ukuqinisekisa nokuqapha (ubufakazi, izifakazelo, ukuqapha ukuhambisana ngaphandle kokwethembana)
  • NRS-H61 Umndeni wezingozi: Ukwehluleka okulandelanayo (NHS-1 sys.cascade)
  • NRS-H62 Umndeni wezingozi: Izehlakalo ezihlangene nezezingozi eziningi (NHS-1 sys.compound)
  • NRS-H60 Umndeni wezingozi: Ukuphazamiseka kochungechunge lokuhlinzeka nokugeleza (NHS-1 sys.supply-chain)
  • NRS-H94 Umndeni wezingozi: Izehlakalo ze-inthanethi zesistimu (NHS-1 cyber.systemic-cyber)
  • NRS-H107 Umndeni wezingozi: Ukugxila nokufana kwengqalasizinda yedijithali (NHS-1 tech.digital-concentration)
  • NRS-H7 Umndeni wezingozi: Ukungajwayeleki kokujikeleza okukhulu komoya (NHS-1 atmo.climate-mode)

Observation

  • Copernicus EMS rapid mapping activations (listed for reference)
  • OpenStreetMap planet and replication (listed for reference)
  • ERA5 reanalysis (Copernicus Climate Data Store) (listed for reference)
  • Direct economic loss attributed to disasters in relation to global GDP
  • Number of disruptions to basic services attributed to disasters

Example geography

  • Bangladesh: 134 hexagonal cells
  • Night lights tonight, outages (VIIRS Day/Night Band), NASA GIBS
  • Carbon monoxide, smoke transport (AIRS), NASA GIBS
  • Vegetation disturbance alerts, 30 m (OPERA DIST-ALERT), NASA GIBS
08Imithombo

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

UmthomboWhat it givesLicence class
CMIP6 archive via the Earth System Grid FederationClimate model outputs from common experimentsOpen, CC BY 4.0 for most models (to check per model)
ISIMIP repositoryImpact model outputs for water, agriculture, health and other sectorsOpen, licence per dataset (to check)
AgMIP crop model intercomparisonsCrop model ensemble protocols and resultsPublic, terms per project
Scenario Modeling Hub publications for epidemicsMulti-model epidemic scenario projectionsPublic, terms per hub
Literature on model genealogy and ensemble independenceAnalysis of shared model componentsLicence per publication
09Methods and evidence

How model intercomparison is modelled, measured and tested.

The model, its assumptions, its data and its uncertainty, in the form a scientist or engineer would check. Structures follow published methods. The values drawn are illustrative, not findings.

Model, equations and assumptions

The model structure used for model intercomparison, the assumptions it makes and how each is tested.

Risk of element iRi = f(Hi, Ei, Vi, Ci)hazard, exposure, vulnerability and coping capacity
Expected annual lossEAL = ∑k pk · Lkover events k with annual probability pk
Coupled systemsxt+1 = A xt + B ut + εtA carries the couplings, u the shock, ε the error
AssumptionWhy it is madeHow it is tested
Hazard and exposure are independent within an eventKeeps the loss integral tractableCompare with a copula fit on joint records
Couplings are linear near the operating pointLets shocks propagate through APerturb beyond the linear range and compare
Vulnerability curves transfer between placesLocal curves are rarely availableValidate against observed losses where they exist
Inputs
versioned datasets with provenance
Okuphumayo
distributions, never single numbers
Code
released with the model card and tests
Reproduction
same data, code, environment and seed
Standard risk and state-space formulations; the assumptions listed are typical of the method, stated for review, not results.
FAIR guiding principles · GO FAIR and FORCE11W3C PROV · World Wide Web ConsortiumGuidance on consistent treatment of uncertainties · IPCCCEOS Analysis Ready Data · Committee on Earth Observation Satellites
10Decisions

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

Systems Science and Modelling prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

Ubani onqumayoThe questionEvidence this page serves
Modelling groupsWhich experiments and protocols to adoptProtocol designs; evaluation reports
Institutions using model resultsHow much confidence to place in ensemble findingsEnsemble summaries with spread
Research fundersWhether to fund intercomparison infrastructureEvidence on value of intercomparison

Outputs this topic produces

  • Intercomparison protocol designs for cross-sector models
  • Ensemble summaries with spread and agreement stated
  • Model evaluation reports against observations
  • Method notes in Reports Methods and Technical
11Core questions

What experts ask about intercomparison.

  • Do independently built models agree, and on which outputs?
  • Where they disagree, is it because of structure, parameters, inputs or errors?
  • Is the spread of an ensemble a meaningful measure of uncertainty?
  • Are the models truly independent, or do they share code, data and assumptions?
  • How should results be weighted when some models perform better against observations?
12Mechanisms and drivers

What disagreement tells you.

Every model embodies choices: which processes to include, how to represent them and how to calibrate them. Two well-built models can therefore produce different answers. When models agree, confidence increases, though not to certainty, since they may share the same flaw. When they disagree, the disagreement is information: it reveals structural uncertainty that no single model can show.

Interpreting an ensemble is not straightforward. Models are rarely independent; many share components, data or lineage. An ensemble’s spread may underestimate true uncertainty if the models share errors, or overstate it if poor models are included. Methods for weighting models by performance and independence are an active research area.

Intercomparison also improves models. Diagnosing why one model differs often reveals errors or missing processes, and shared protocols raise standards across a community.

13Methods and data

Methods and their limits.

  1. 01

    Common protocols

    Shared inputs, scenarios, output variables and formats. Designing them takes time and agreement.

  2. 02

    Ensemble statistics

    Means, spreads and distributions across models, using probability and statistics. Spread is not a probability unless justified.

  3. 03

    Performance and independence weighting

    Weighting models by skill and distinctness, using uncertainty quantification. Weights depend on chosen metrics.

  4. 04

    Process diagnostics

    Comparing internal variables to find sources of difference. Requires access to model internals.

Agreement among models is not proof of correctness. Intercomparison results state which models took part and how they relate.

14Izindlela

How it is studied, and what the methods cannot say.

15Where this page’s references

Where this page’s references lead.

The bodies and documents this page is read against. Status and editions change; each link goes to the issuing body.

16Imibuzo

Questions and answers.

What is a model intercomparison project?
A coordinated effort in which several modelling groups run the same experiments with shared inputs and output formats, so that their results can be compared systematically.
Does agreement between models mean they are right?
Not necessarily. Models can share errors through common components and assumptions. Agreement increases confidence only when models are evaluated against observations.
What is structural uncertainty?
Uncertainty that comes from the way a model is built, such as which processes it includes and how, which shows up as differences between models.
Does intercomparison find the best model?
It can show which models perform better on chosen tests, but different models may be better for different purposes.
Why not just average the models?
Because models are not independent and not equally good. Simple averages can mislead without considering both.
Can private models take part?
Intercomparisons can be designed to include them, with rules on what is disclosed. Each protocol states its rules.
Is the Universe exercise an intercomparison?
The designed cross-system integration exercise uses intercomparison methods, described on the Universe page.
ImibikoNikela

Nikela ngobufakazi kusuka kuleli khasi.

Reports is the Consortium’s quarterly publication. What you know about this subject can become evidence, a case or a correction in the next edition, credited to you and published under CC BY 4.0 where it is your own work.

GCRIIsayensi Yezinhlelo Nokwakha AmamodeliIzindlela NezobuchwephesheIsimo Nokuhlolwa Kwengcindezi
Isayensi Yezinhlelo Nokwakha Amamodeli

Bring a method, a dataset or a question.

Information and enquiries are open today. An enquiry receives a reference and names the next step; applications, payments, compute allocations and registrations open only when their team, terms and review capacity exist.