Skip to content

GCRI · Disaster Resilience and Recovery · Foundations

Multi-hazard exercises: the foundations of testing disaster plans before they are needed

Multi-hazard exercises are planned rehearsals, from tabletop discussions to live drills, in which organisations and communities test their plans, procedures and coordination against realistic scenarios. This foundational guide explains the types of exercise, how they are designed and evaluated, what the evidence shows and the standards that govern them.

Em
28 October 2026
Leitura
15 minutes
Evidências
18 sources, cited in order
Método
A synthesis of the Sendai Framework and agreed UN terminology, Secretary-General reports, international standards on exercises, crisis management and capability assessment, national exercising guidance, World Health Organization guidance on simulation exercises and after-action reviews, and the handbook of a regional tsunami exercise, following an exercise from objective to scenario, delivery, evaluation and lessons.
Dados
The article relies on published guidance and standards and on qualitative reports of exercises in UN documents; the regional tsunami exercise handbook and its scenario parameters are published by the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission; displacement figures from pre-emptive evacuations come from the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre.
NEXUS TWIN · WF-1 · SURFACESEED efd6898eG-P03.MULTI-HAZARD-EXERCISES.FOUNDATIONSxyzSCHEMATIC · SURFACEST-01 · 0.537 0.457ST-02 · 0.643 0.343
WF-1 · surface Schematic wireframe twin (surface, hazard footprint). An illustration, not data.

Métodos e evidência

Pergunta
What are multi-hazard exercises, how are they designed, run and evaluated, and what do they add to disaster preparedness?
Abordagem
A synthesis of the Sendai Framework and agreed UN terminology, Secretary-General reports, international standards on exercises, crisis management and capability assessment, national exercising guidance, World Health Organization guidance on simulation exercises and after-action reviews, and the handbook of a regional tsunami exercise, following an exercise from objective to scenario, delivery, evaluation and lessons.
Evidências
18 sources, cited in order and listed under References
Data availability
The article relies on published guidance and standards and on qualitative reports of exercises in UN documents; the regional tsunami exercise handbook and its scenario parameters are published by the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission; displacement figures from pre-emptive evacuations come from the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre.
Limites
There is no global dataset on how many exercises are held or what they change, and most evaluations are internal and unpublished. Exercises test arrangements against scenarios, which may differ from real events. The article is not an exercise plan or an instruction for any organisation.

01Definição

What multi-hazard exercises are

Rehearsals that test arrangements against scenarios, for one or several hazards.

Multi-hazard exercises are planned events in which organisations and communities rehearse and test their disaster plans, procedures and coordination against realistic scenarios, for a single hazard or for several hazards that occur together or in sequence. The World Health Organization (WHO) defines a simulation exercise as a form of practice, training, monitoring or evaluation of capabilities involving the description or simulation of an emergency, to which a described or simulated response is made 1.

Exercises are part of preparedness. The agreed UN terminology lists training and field exercises among preparedness activities and says that contingency plans need to be regularly updated and exercised 7. The Sendai Framework asks governments to promote regular disaster preparedness, response and recovery exercises, including evacuation drills, and to support regional cooperation through common exercises and drills 3.

The multi-hazard element matters because real disasters rarely respect a single plan. The CARIBE WAVE tsunami exercise handbook, for example, reminds planners that earthquake shaking near the source can hinder evacuation and add debris to the waves, so tsunami plans that ignore the earthquake are incomplete 6.

This article is the hub of the multi-hazard exercises topic on the Disaster Resilience and Recovery platform. The plans that exercises test are covered in the platform's foundational article on preparedness and continuity.

02Stakes

Why exercises matter

Untested plans are assumptions; exercises find the gaps first.

UK government guidance puts the point directly: planning and preparation for risks cannot be considered reliable until they have been exercised and shown to be workable 2. Exercises let people practise their roles and test procedures and mechanisms, so that gaps are found before an actual emergency 1.

Coordination is where plans most often fail, and coordination is hard to test any other way. The 2023 midterm review of the Sendai Framework found minimal evidence of improvement in coordination mechanisms and noted that siloed disaster risk reduction agencies and policies continue to limit integrated decisions 8. A multi-agency exercise puts those silos in the same room.

Exercises also prepare the public. The Secretary-General reports that community education campaigns, simulation exercises and preparedness frameworks such as the National Tsunami Ready Board of Seychelles improved local readiness for coastal hazards in 2025, and that in Nepal regular training and simulations support households in acting early ahead of floods and heatwaves 9.

03Tipos

Types of exercise

From discussion to live play, each type tests something different.

UK government guidance summarises three exercise types: tabletop, stress test and live play 4. A tabletop exercise is a discussion-based, seminar or meeting style event of typically short duration, hours not days, used to examine, explore and familiarise individuals and teams with risks and impacts, existing response plans and command and control systems and structures; it needs relatively little preparation time and is useful for bringing multi-agency training audiences together 4.

A stress test is a discussion-based exercise that challenges players' planning assumptions and operating procedures, typically used to stress test developing contingency plans or to examine response options to a new risk or a low probability, high impact risk; the guidance describes its approach as constructively adversarial 4. A live play exercise is an event designed to test individuals and teams in real time, using techniques, drills and equipment in as close a replication of real events as possible; it is often used at lower operational levels to test key skills and drills against key performance indicators or to validate against minimum preparedness levels 4.

The Sendai Framework names evacuation drills explicitly 3. ISO 22398:2013 gives guidelines for planning, conducting and improving exercise projects within an exercise programme, for organisations of any type or size 10. The UK guidance sets out these types, with their features and applications, in its Annex A 4.

04Desenho

Designing an exercise

Aim, objectives, scenario and the people who make it work.

Good exercises start with a clear aim and measurable objectives. UK guidance sets five principles: exercises must be well planned, realistic, challenging, evaluated and used to identify lessons, and supportive of but not a replacement for other training 2. Its worked example sets an outcome of rehearsing and evaluating a multi-agency crisis concept of operations against a reasonable worst-case scenario, with objectives such as operating at full capacity for 48 hours 2.

Scenarios should come from risk assessments. National guidance draws reasonable worst-case scenarios from the national risk assessment 2, and the tsunami exercise described below builds each scenario from a modelled earthquake or volcanic flank collapse and its simulated warning messages 6. A multi-hazard scenario adds secondary effects, such as the earthquake damage that can hinder tsunami evacuation, which the CARIBE WAVE handbook asks planners to consider 6.

Roles need to be named. UK guidance separates the planning team, the exercise players and an evaluator who agrees the evaluation plan, directs the evaluation team and writes the report 2. Exercising is organised in tiers in the UK national programme, from central crisis arrangements through departmental exercises to regional and local exercises 2.

05Avaliação

Evaluation and after-action review

How exercises and real responses become lessons.

Evaluation turns an exercise from an event into evidence. UK guidance defines it as a systematic assessment of exercise objectives, design and delivery against recognised, predetermined criteria, so that differences between intended and actual outcomes can be found 2. The CARIBE WAVE exercise asks every participating Member State and territory to complete a post-exercise evaluation, and publishes an evaluation report as a second volume of its handbook 6.

After-action reviews do the same for real events. WHO's guidance for after-action review describes four formats, a debrief, a working group, key informant interviews and a mixed method, and includes specific guidance for reviewing the health sector's part in the response to natural disasters 5. The WHO lists simulation exercises and after-action reviews among the tools for monitoring and evaluating International Health Regulations capacities, alongside annual reporting and voluntary joint external evaluation 1,11.

Lessons must be acted on. The Secretary-General names after-action reviews as a way to drive continuous improvement of early warning systems 9, and ISO 22361:2022 on crisis management devotes a clause to training, validation and learning from crises 12. An exercise whose lessons are recorded but not implemented has tested the plan without improving it.

06Regional

Regional and cross-border exercises

Exercising warning chains that cross borders, using tsunamis as the clearest example.

Hazards that cross borders need exercises that cross borders. The Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO runs regional tsunami exercises; the CARIBE WAVE 26 handbook describes an annual exercise of the Caribbean tsunami warning system held on 19 March 2026, patterned on exercises since 2011 and on the Pacific Wave exercises that began in 2008 6.

The 2026 exercise offered two scenarios, a tsunami from a magnitude 7.6 earthquake southwest of the Cayman Islands and one from a flank collapse of the Kick 'em Jenny submarine volcano, with simulated warning messages covering a period from five minutes to three and a half hours after origin 6. It also tested communication between the regional warning centre and maritime safety operators 6.

Exercises and real events reinforce each other. The Secretary-General reports that tsunami evacuation drills and awareness campaigns have strengthened community preparedness in Asia and the Pacific, and that simulation exercises in Madagascar, Mauritius, Seychelles and the United Republic of Tanzania enhanced system readiness 13. In 2025, tsunami alerts in Chile and Japan prompted nearly 1.6 million pre-emptive evacuations, and the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre draws lessons from them on the protective value of evacuation 14.

07Exemplos

Two examples: evacuation drills and anticipatory action simulations

What sustained drilling and simulation look like in practice.

Chile shows what years of drilling can build. The Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre reports that after the 2010 earthquake and tsunami exposed gaps in risk assessment, technology and warnings, Chile invested in regular drills, information campaigns and disaster risk education in schools, and that around 14 million people have taken part in earthquake and tsunami drills since 2015 14. It notes that these exercises normalise pre-emptive movement, reduce stress during evacuations and help households rehearse what to do, and links them to the strong uptake of evacuation alerts in 2025 14.

Anticipatory action is now exercised too. The Anticipation Hub reports that good practice includes stress-testing existing anticipatory action frameworks to check that actions can be carried out when plausible hazards occur at the same time or one after another, for example through simulation exercises such as one conducted in Madagascar 15. In Saint Lucia, a real-time hurricane simulation in 2025 tested making anticipatory payments through the social protection system 15.

Both examples test the hand-offs that plans assume: from alert to movement, and from trigger to payment. The platform's anticipatory action topic and early warning readiness topic cover those systems.

08Multi-hazard

Multi-hazard and cascading scenarios

Why compound scenarios test what single-hazard plans miss.

Real events combine hazards and failures. A multi-hazard exercise can inject a power cut into a flood response, a heatwave into an epidemic, or a communications failure into an evacuation. The UK guidance describes the stress test as an exercise used to challenge planning assumptions and to examine response options to a new risk or a low probability, high impact risk 4.

Compound scenarios also test the warning chain. The Secretary-General notes that gaps persist in turning warnings into anticipatory action, particularly in making messages timely, accessible and actionable for the most vulnerable 13. Exercises that include people with disabilities, older people and non-native speakers are the practical way to find those gaps; ISO 22395:2018 gives guidance on involving and supporting vulnerable persons in emergency preparation, response and recovery 16.

Capability assessment frames what to test. ISO 22325:2016 gives guidelines for assessing emergency management capability with a model of four levels, eight indicators and an assessment process 17. Hazard science for building scenarios is covered on the Climate and Hazards platform's compound hazards topic.

09Beyond government

Exercising beyond government

Businesses, schools, hospitals and communities exercise too.

Exercises are not only for civil protection agencies. The Secretary-General reports that the UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR) supported more than 250 small and medium-sized businesses with business continuity planning, crisis simulations and assessments of financing options 9. Health systems use the WHO simulation exercise manual, which provides an overview of the exercise tools and guidelines WHO uses for outbreaks and public health emergencies 1.

Communities practise through drills and awareness days. World Tsunami Awareness Day, observed on 5 November, galvanises political commitment, and community-based education campaigns and simulation exercises have improved risk literacy and local readiness 9. The platform's community and local preparedness topic covers how households and local groups prepare.

Incident management standards make joint exercises possible. ISO 22320:2018 gives guidelines for incident management when two or more organisations work together, covering roles, resources and joint direction 18; an exercise is the usual way to check that those arrangements hold.

10Pitfalls

Common pitfalls

Why exercises fail to teach, and how guidance tries to prevent it.

Exercises can mislead as well as teach. UK guidance warns of optimism bias, the tendency to overestimate the chance of good outcomes and underestimate bad ones, and gives the example of treating a lack of reports about an impact as proof that it is not happening 2. It asks planners to make explicit, evidence-based adjustments to the estimates in any activity they exercise 2.

Purpose comes first. The same guidance says the most important question is what the exercise is for, summarised in a single master question from which the method, analysis plan, scenario and data capture follow 2. It treats an exercise that produces no lessons as a sign that the objectives or design were wrong, and says that not achieving the desired outcomes in an exercise is acceptable and can be essential 2.

Exercises are not a complete training programme. Participants should receive role training or briefings beforehand, so that exercise time is spent exercising rather than learning roles 2. The platform's page on the social science of disasters covers the behavioural research behind these warnings.

11Evidências

What the evidence shows

Exercises are widely recommended, but outcome evidence is thin.

Exercises are part of formal capacity monitoring in health. The WHO International Health Regulations monitoring and evaluation framework combines annual reporting, voluntary joint external evaluation, after-action reviews and simulation exercises, with after-action reviews described as a qualitative review of actions taken to identify best practices, lessons and gaps 11. WHO notes that simulation exercises were identified as a key component in validating core capacities under the framework noted by the World Health Assembly 1.

UN reports describe exercises as contributing to readiness in specific countries, such as the simulation exercises in four Indian Ocean States 13 and the training and simulations behind community early action in Nepal 9. These are qualitative reports from implementing partners, not measured outcomes.

There is no global count of exercises held or of the changes they produce, and most evaluation reports are internal. The platform's methods and uncertainty page records how such evidence is treated. A useful test for any exercise programme is whether lessons identified in exercises reappear in after-action reviews of real events.

TipoFormatoTypical use
Exercício de simulação de mesa 4Discussion, hours not daysExamine risks, plans and command structures; build multi-agency understanding
teste de estresse 2Structured, constructively adversarial discussionChallenge assumptions; new or low-probability, high-impact risks
Live play exercise 4Real time, with drills and equipmentTest skills and procedures against performance indicators
Regional tsunami exercise 6Simulated warning messages over 3.5 hoursTest warning communication and national response
Revisão pós-ação 5Debrief, working group, interviews or mixedLearn from a real response
Table 1. Types of exercise and what each tests, from UK government guidance, as of 28 October 2026.

12Instrumentos

Standards and guidance for exercises

Global frameworks, international standards and national and sector guidance.

The Sendai Framework sets the expectation of regular exercises and regional drills 3. International standards cover the method: ISO 22398 for exercise programmes 10, ISO 22361 for crisis management capability including validation and learning 12, ISO 22325 for capability assessment 17 and ISO 22320 for incident management 18.

Sector and national guidance adds practice: WHO's simulation exercise manual and after-action review guidance for health 1,5, the UK Exercising Best Practice Guidance of 2024 for government and resilience professionals 2, and the IOC's exercise handbooks for tsunami warning systems 6.

The UK guidance gives examples of evaluation methodologies in its annexes 4, and WHO's after-action review guidance describes reviews of real responses 5. The platform's preparedness and continuity topic covers the plans being tested.

InstrumentoIssuerSituaçãoFunção
Sendai Framework, paragraphs 33(h) and 34(f) 3UN General AssemblyIn force to 2030Regular exercises and regional drills
ISO 22398:2013 10ISOConfirmed 2022Guidelines for exercises
ISO 22361:2022 12ISOPublished 2022Crisis management, including validation
WHO simulation exercise manual 1WHOPublished 2017Health emergency exercises
WHO after-action review guidance 5WHOPublished 2019Reviewing real responses
Exercising Best Practice Guidance 2UK governmentPublished 2024National exercising practice
Table 2. Instruments that shape multi-hazard exercises, and their status as of 28 October 2026.

13Frontiers

What is changing in exercising

Four areas where practice is moving.

Compound and systemic scenarios. The UK guidance describes stress tests as used for developing contingency plans and for new or low probability, high impact risks 4.

Exercising anticipatory action. The Secretary-General reports that simulation exercises improved readiness, and that gaps remain in turning warnings into anticipatory action 9,13.

Inclusive exercises. Guidance on vulnerable persons supports exercises that include the people most at risk 16.

Linking exercises to real events. The Secretary-General reports that after-action reviews drive continuous improvement 9, and WHO guidance describes four formats for them 5.

14Consórcio

Three faces of exercising across the Consortium

Evidence, governance and finance for tested plans.

Within the Consortium, The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI) leads on science, technology and evidence: scenario design, simulation and the evaluation methods that turn exercises into evidence, through the Disaster Resilience and Recovery platform and its pages on decision analysis for disaster risk and operations research for disaster logistics. Nexus Foundry is operated at national and regional level by Nexus Consortiums through their host and lead organisations, within a multilateral programme led by these three pillar not-for-profit institutions on a public-private-planet partnership.

The Global Risks Forum (GRF) leads on governance and cooperation. Its topic on simulation and after action covers how exercises inform governance, its Diplomacy platform covers cross-border cooperation, and its Climate and Nature Governance platform covers adaptation institutions.

The Global Risks Alliance (GRA) translates exercise evidence into finance questions, without lending, underwriting or rating, through its topic on claims and operational resilience. Work moves between the three in a cycle from question to evidence, analysis, publication in Reports and decision by competent authorities.

What this article does not claim: it explains multi-hazard exercises and the public guidance on them. It is not an exercise plan, a scenario for any real place or an instruction for any organisation; exercises should follow the requirements of the responsible authorities. GCRI does not regulate or certify, GRF does not regulate or finance, and GRA does not lend, underwrite or rate. Naming an organisation, exercise or standard is not a claim of partnership, endorsement or deployment.

Perguntas

Perguntas e respostas

O que é um exercício de mesa?

A discussion-based, seminar-style exercise, usually lasting hours, in which participants talk through a scenario to examine risks, plans and command structures 2.

What is the difference between an exercise and an after-action review?

An exercise tests arrangements against a simulated scenario; an after-action review examines what was done in a real response to identify lessons and gaps 1,5.

How often should disaster plans be exercised?

The Sendai Framework calls for regular exercises, and the agreed UN terminology says contingency plans need to be regularly updated and exercised 3,7. The interval is set by national and sector rules.

Is there an international standard for exercises?

Yes. ISO 22398:2013 gives guidelines for planning, conducting and improving exercise projects within an exercise programme 10.

What makes an exercise multi-hazard?

A scenario in which several hazards or failures occur together or in sequence, so that interactions between plans are tested, as in tsunami exercises that also consider earthquake damage hindering evacuation 6.

Termos

Glossário

Exercício de simulação de mesa
A short, discussion-based exercise that walks participants through a scenario to examine plans and roles.
Live play exercise
An exercise that tests people and teams in real time with drills and equipment, as close to a real event as possible.
Inject
A piece of scenario information introduced during an exercise to prompt decisions.
Revisão pós-ação
A structured review of a real response to identify what worked, what did not and what to change.
Exercise evaluation
A systematic assessment of exercise objectives, design and delivery against predetermined criteria.

Reuse and cite

Text CC BY 4.0. Cite the page with its date; data tables are linked under each figure.

Fontes

Referências

18 sources, numbered in the order they are first cited
  1. World Health Organization (2017-02-01). WHO Simulation Exercise Manual. www.who.int. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  2. UK Cabinet Office (UK Resilience Academy) (2024-09-30). Exercising Best Practice Guidance. www.gov.uk. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  3. United Nations General Assembly (2015-06-03). Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 (General Assembly resolution A/RES/69/283). documents.un.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  4. UK Cabinet Office (UK Resilience Academy) (Annexes and resources, HTML edition). Exercising Best Practice Guidance: annexes and resources. www.gov.uk. Accessed 2026-11-17.
  5. World Health Organization (2019-04-01). Guidance for after action review (AAR). www.who.int. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  6. Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO (2026-01-20). Exercise CARIBE WAVE 26: A Caribbean and Adjacent Region Tsunami Warning Exercise, 19 March 2026. Volume 1: Participant's Handbook (IOC Technical Series 198). www.oceanexpert.net. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  7. United Nations General Assembly (2016-12-01). Report of the open-ended intergovernmental expert working group on indicators and terminology relating to disaster risk reduction (A/71/644), welcomed in resolution 71/276. documents.un.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  8. UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (2023-01-31). Main findings and recommendations of the midterm review of the implementation of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 (A/77/640). documents.un.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  9. United Nations Secretary-General (2026-07-31). Implementation of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030: Report of the Secretary-General (A/81/307). documents.un.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  10. International Organization for Standardization (2013-09-01). ISO 22398:2013 Societal security: Guidelines for exercises. committee.iso.org. Accessed 2026-11-17.
  11. World Health Organization (Web page, current as of 2026-10-28). International Health Regulations Monitoring and Evaluation Framework. www.who.int. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  12. International Organization for Standardization (2022-10-01). ISO 22361:2022 Security and resilience: Crisis management, Guidelines. committee.iso.org. Accessed 2026-11-17.
  13. United Nations Secretary-General (2025-08-11). Implementation of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030: Report of the Secretary-General (A/80/333). documents.un.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  14. Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (2026-05-12). Global Report on Internal Displacement 2026. www.internal-displacement.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  15. Anticipation Hub (2026-05-28). Anticipatory action in 2025: a global overview. www.anticipation-hub.org. Accessed 2026-10-28.
  16. International Organization for Standardization (2018-10-01). ISO 22395:2018 Security and resilience: Community resilience, Guidelines for supporting vulnerable persons in an emergency. committee.iso.org. Accessed 2026-11-17.
  17. International Organization for Standardization (2016-10-01). ISO 22325:2016 Security and resilience: Emergency management, Guidelines for capability assessment. committee.iso.org. Accessed 2026-11-17.
  18. International Organization for Standardization (2018-11-01). ISO 22320:2018 Security and resilience: Emergency management, Guidelines for incident management. committee.iso.org. Accessed 2026-11-17.

Registro

Editorial record

Facts and policies are stated as of 28 October 2026. This article is reviewed at least every 180 days and whenever a cited source changes, including the CARIBE WAVE 26 evaluation report, revisions of the cited ISO standards and the next Secretary-General report on the Sendai Framework.

Published by the GCRI editorial desk for the Disaster Resilience and Recovery platform. To report an error or request a correction, use the platform's corrections and concerns route; corrections are dated and listed with the article.

Text is published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence (CC BY 4.0): reuse it with credit to GCRI and a link to this page. Third-party data keep their own terms.

Cite this article

GCRI editorial desk (2026, October 28). Multi-hazard exercises explained: drills, tabletops, reviews. Disaster Resilience and Recovery. https://therisk.global/disaster-resilience/multi-hazard-exercises/

Republish

Republish or translate this article free of charge, in print or online, under CC BY 4.0: keep the byline and Disaster Resilience and Recovery, link to the original and note any change. Figures, maps and twins made by the institutions carry the same licence; third-party data keeps its own credit line.

Attribution to paste
<p>Multi-hazard exercises: the foundations of testing disaster plans before they are needed — GCRI editorial desk, Disaster Resilience and Recovery. First published 28 October 2026 at <a href="https://therisk.global/disaster-resilience/multi-hazard-exercises/">https://therisk.global/disaster-resilience/multi-hazard-exercises/</a>. Republished under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).</p>

Related across the Consortium

Parcela

EmailLinkedInBlueskyMastodon

The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI Canada) is a Canadian not-for-profit organisation, not a registered charity, with its registered office in Ontario.