References and record
Every source the edition rests on, the publication record, the corrections log and the open record.
فهرست مطالب
- ·Edition home
- ·Executive summary
- 1Materials are a discovery claim, a supply chain and a safety question
- 2Key findings
- 3Systems and sectors at baseline
- 4Risks and capability
- 5Reliance on claimed materials before independent synthesis
- 6Readings from the other desks
- 7The 2027 agenda
- 8Systems in depth
- Aروششناسی
- BData appendix
- CReferences and record
- ·Complete edition, for print
C.142 sources
NR-CIT-1, editor first. A DOI is linked where the source has one; Nexus records carry a UNI once the catalogue allocates it (NS-1).
- 1Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (ed.), Press release: Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2025, awarded to Kitagawa, Robson and Yaghi for the development of metal-organic frameworks (8 October 2025; uses named: harvesting water from desert air, capturing carbon dioxide, separating PFAS from water). NobelPrize.org, Stockholm. Observation year 2025. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 2Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (ed.), Press release: The Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2023, awarded to Bawendi, Brus and Yekimov for the discovery and synthesis of quantum dots (4 October 2023). NobelPrize.org, Stockholm. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 6, chapter 8
- 3Nobel Assembly at Karolinska Institutet (ed.), Press release: The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 2023, awarded to Karikó and Weissman for nucleoside base modifications that enabled mRNA vaccines (2 October 2023; the text notes that delivery required carrier lipid systems). NobelPrize.org, Stockholm. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 3, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 4Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (ed.), Press release: The Nobel Prize in Physics 2010, awarded to Geim and Novoselov for experiments on the two-dimensional material graphene (5 October 2010). NobelPrize.org, Stockholm. Observation year 2010. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 6, chapter 8
- 5Merchant, A., Batzner, S., Schoenholz, S.S., Aykol, M., Cheon, G. and Cubuk, E.D., Scaling deep learning for materials discovery, Nature 624, 80 to 85, 2023 (abstract record read: 48,000 known stable crystals; 2.2 million structures below the convex hull; 736 independently realised; the full text was not read). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 6Szymanski, N.J. et al., An autonomous laboratory for the accelerated synthesis of novel materials, Nature 624, 86 to 91, 2023 (abstract record read: 41 compounds from 58 targets in 17 days; the full text was not read). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 7Zeni, C. et al., A generative model for inorganic materials design, Nature, 2025, pages 624 to 632 (abstract record read: more than twice as likely to be new and stable; one structure synthesised within 20% of target; first published 16 January 2025). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2025. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 8Cheetham, A.K. and Seshadri, R., Artificial intelligence driving materials discovery? Perspective on the article Scaling Deep Learning for Materials Discovery, Chemistry of Materials, 2024, pages 3490 to 3495 (abstract record read: scant evidence for compounds that fulfil novelty, credibility and utility). American Chemical Society, Washington. Observation year 2024. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 9Leeman, J., Liu, Y., Stiles, J., Lee, S.B., Bhatt, P., Schoop, L.M. and Palgrave, R.G., Challenges in high-throughput inorganic materials prediction and autonomous synthesis, PRX Energy 3, 011002, 2024 (abstract read on a public repository page: 43 products examined; about two thirds of claimed successes likely known disordered phases). American Physical Society, College Park. Observation year 2024. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 5, chapter 6, chapter 7, chapter 8
- 10Google DeepMind (ed.), Millions of new materials discovered with deep learning (company blog post, 29 November 2023; states 2.2 million new crystals, 380,000 stable, 736 independently created). Google DeepMind, London. Vendor announcement, weak evidence. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 11Microsoft Research (ed.), MatterGen: a new paradigm of materials design with generative AI (company blog post; states a training set of 608,000 stable materials). Microsoft, Redmond. Vendor announcement, weak evidence. Observation year 2025. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 12Kim, H. et al., Water harvesting from air with metal-organic frameworks powered by natural sunlight, Science 356, 430 to 434, 2017 (abstract record read: 2.8 litres of water per kilogram of MOF per day at relative humidity as low as 20%). American Association for the Advancement of Science, Washington. Observation year 2017. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 13Bui, D.T., Chua, K.J. and Gordon, J.M., Comment on Water harvesting from air with metal-organic frameworks powered by natural sunlight, Science, 2017, eaao0791 (abstract record read; the authors of the original paper published a response, eaao3139, that rejects the comparison). American Association for the Advancement of Science, Washington. Observation year 2017. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 14Nature (ed.), LK-99 isn’t a superconductor: how science sleuths solved the mystery, Nature 620, 705, 2023 (news article; the page was opened but only its headline and summary were readable behind the access wall). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 5
- 15Nature (ed.), Retraction Note: Room-temperature superconductivity in a carbonaceous sulfur hydride (published 26 September 2022; the original paper appeared on 14 October 2020; all authors disagreed with the decision). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2022. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 5, chapter 7
- 16Nature (ed.), Retraction Note: Evidence of near-ambient superconductivity in a N-doped lutetium hydride, Nature, 2023 (publication record read; the note text was not available in the record). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 5, chapter 7
- 17US Geological Survey (ed.), Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 (full report downloaded and read for natural graphite, gallium, rare earths and the foreign trade section; doi 10.3133/mcs2026). USGS, Reston. Observation year 2025. Accessed 2026-11-03. doi:10.3133/mcs2026 Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 7, chapter 8
- 18European Commission (ed.), Critical Raw Materials Act (policy page: 2030 benchmarks of 10% extraction, 40% processing, 25% recycling and no more than 65% from a single third country). Directorate-General for Internal Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs, Brussels. Observation year 2024. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 19European Commission (eds.), Safe and sustainable by design (policy page, revised March 2026) and news article of 8 December 2022 on the Recommendation. Directorate-General for Research and Innovation, Brussels. Observation year 2026. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 20International Agency for Research on Cancer (ed.), Some Nanomaterials and Some Fibres, IARC Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, Volume 111, 2017 (publication page: first assessment of single-walled and multiwalled carbon nanotubes; classifications were not read). IARC, Lyon. Observation year 2017. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in the summary, chapter 1, chapter 2, chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 21National Nanotechnology Coordination Office (ed.), About the National Nanotechnology Initiative (programme page: over thirty federal departments, independent agencies and commissions). NNCO, Alexandria. Observation year 2026. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 22Materials Genome Initiative (ed.), MGI home page (programme page: a federal multi-agency initiative for discovering, manufacturing and deploying advanced materials twice as fast and at a fraction of the cost). US Government, Washington. Observation year 2026. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 3, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 23Zhang, B. et al., A cross-linked molecular contact for stable operation of perovskite/silicon tandem solar cells, Science, 2025, pages 837 to 842 (abstract record read: resistance of conventional monomeric contacts rises about sixfold at elevated temperature). American Association for the Advancement of Science, Washington. Observation year 2025. Accessed 2026-11-03. Cited in chapter 3, chapter 6
- 24International Energy Agency (ed.), Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026, revised version, July 2026 (full report opened; export controls table: China 99% of gallium and 94% of refined graphite in 2025, with the ban on gallium exports to the United States suspended for one year; one-year suspension in November 2025 of the October 2025 rare earth controls). IEA, Paris. Observation year 2025. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 25European Commission (ed.), Commission Recommendation of 10 June 2022 on the definition of nanomaterial, 2022/C 229/01, Official Journal of the European Union C 229, 14 June 2022 (text opened: 50% or more of particles in the number-based size distribution with an external dimension of 1 nm to 100 nm; updates Recommendation 2011/696/EU). European Commission, Brussels. Observation year 2022. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 26European Commission (ed.), Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/1881 of 3 December 2018 amending REACH Annexes I, III, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI and XII to address nanoforms of substances, Official Journal of the European Union L 308, 4 December 2018 (text opened; applies from 1 January 2020). European Union, Brussels. Observation year 2020. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 27US Environmental Protection Agency (ed.), Chemical substances when manufactured or processed as nanoscale materials; TSCA reporting and recordkeeping requirements, final rule, Federal Register 82 FR 3641, 12 January 2017 (Federal Register record opened: one-time reporting for existing discrete nanoscale forms and standing reporting for new forms; effective date extended to 14 August 2017 by 82 FR 22088). EPA, Washington. Observation year 2017. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 4, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 28OECD (ed.), Test No. 125: Nanomaterial particle size and size distribution of nanomaterials, OECD Guidelines for the Testing of Chemicals, Section 1, 4 July 2023 (Crossref publication record read; a nanomaterial-specific test guideline; the OECD programme pages were not reachable). OECD Publishing, Paris. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 4, chapter 6
- 29ISO (ed.), ISO 80004-1:2023, Nanotechnologies: vocabulary, part 1, core vocabulary, published 26 July 2023 by ISO/TC 229 (ISO open data deliverables record read; it replaces ISO/TS 80004-1:2015, now withdrawn). International Organization for Standardization, Geneva. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 6
- 30ISO (ed.), ISO/TC 229 Nanotechnologies, technical committee (ISO open data deliverables file read: 225 deliverables owned by the committee, 46 of them currently published). International Organization for Standardization, Geneva. Observation year 2026. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 4, chapter 6
- 31Rauscher, H., Kestens, V., Rasmussen, K., Linsinger, T. and Stefaniak, E., Guidance on the implementation of the Commission Recommendation 2022/C 229/01 on the definition of nanomaterial, JRC Science for Policy Report, EUR 31452 EN, 24 April 2023 (repository record and abstract read: key terms, a decision tree and measurement-based identification). Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 6, chapter 8
- 32National Laboratory of the Rockies, formerly the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (ed.), Best Research-Cell Efficiency Chart (programme page opened: highest research-cell efficiencies confirmed by independent test laboratories, plotted from 1976 to the present; no figure is used). NLR, Golden. Observation year 2026. Accessed 2026-11-05.
- 33Graphene Flagship (ed.), About the Graphene Flagship (programme page opened: an initiative funded by the Horizon Europe research and innovation programme that builds on the previous ten years of the Graphene Flagship; no funding total given and no figure is used). Graphene Flagship, Gothenburg. Observation year 2026. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 8
- 34US Department of Energy (ed.), Critical Materials Assessment, July 2023 (report opened; criticality assessment of materials for clean energy technologies, funded through the Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies Office; no programme total is given). DOE, Washington. Observation year 2023. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 8
- 35Novoselov, K.S., Geim, A.K., Morozov, S.V., Jiang, D., Zhang, Y., Dubonos, S.V., Grigorieva, I.V. and Firsov, A.A., Electric field effect in atomically thin carbon films, Science 306, 666 to 669, 22 October 2004 (Crossref record and abstract read; doi 10.1126/science.1102896). American Association for the Advancement of Science, Washington. Observation year 2004. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1126/science.1102896 Cited in chapter 6
- 36Li, H., Eddaoudi, M., O’Keeffe, M. and Yaghi, O.M., Design and synthesis of an exceptionally stable and highly porous metal-organic framework, Nature 402, 276 to 279, November 1999 (Crossref record read; doi 10.1038/46248). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 1999. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1038/46248 Cited in chapter 6
- 37Iijima, S., Helical microtubules of graphitic carbon, Nature 354, 56 to 58, November 1991 (Crossref record read; doi 10.1038/354056a0). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 1991. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1038/354056a0 Cited in chapter 6
- 38Jain, A., Ong, S.P., Hautier, G., Chen, W., Richards, W.D., Dacek, S., Cholia, S., Gunter, D. et al., Commentary: The Materials Project: a materials genome approach to accelerating materials innovation, APL Materials 1, 011002, 1 July 2013 (Crossref record read; doi 10.1063/1.4812323). AIP Publishing, Melville. Observation year 2013. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1063/1.4812323 Cited in chapter 6
- 39Poland, C.A., Duffin, R., Kinloch, I., Maynard, A., Wallace, W.A.H., Seaton, A., Stone, V., Brown, S. et al., Carbon nanotubes introduced into the abdominal cavity of mice show asbestos-like pathogenicity in a pilot study, Nature Nanotechnology 3, 423 to 428, 20 May 2008 (Crossref record read; doi 10.1038/nnano.2008.111). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2008. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1038/nnano.2008.111 Cited in chapter 2, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 40Hou, X., Zaks, T., Langer, R. and Dong, Y., Lipid nanoparticles for mRNA delivery, Nature Reviews Materials 6, 1078 to 1094, 10 August 2021 (Crossref record read; doi 10.1038/s41578-021-00358-0). Springer Nature, London. Observation year 2021. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1038/s41578-021-00358-0 Cited in chapter 6, chapter 8
- 41European Parliament and Council (eds.), Regulation (EU) 2024/1252 of 11 April 2024 establishing a framework for ensuring a secure and sustainable supply of critical raw materials, Official Journal of the European Union L series, 3 May 2024 (text opened; Article 5 benchmarks for 2030: at least 10% extraction, 40% processing and 25% recycling of annual consumption of strategic raw materials, and no more than 65% from a single third country). European Union, Brussels. Observation year 2024. Accessed 2026-11-05. Cited in chapter 2, chapter 6, chapter 8
- 42Brus, L.E., Electron-electron and electron-hole interactions in small semiconductor crystallites: the size dependence of the lowest excited electronic state, Journal of Chemical Physics 80, 4403 to 4409, 1 May 1984 (Crossref record read; doi 10.1063/1.447218). AIP Publishing, Melville. Observation year 1984. Accessed 2026-11-05. doi:10.1063/1.447218 Cited in chapter 6
C.2Publication record
انتشار
- عنوان
- Exponential Technology Report 2026: Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology, Baseline Edition
- مجموعه
- Reports · Exponential Technology Series XT-12
- ویراست
- Baseline Edition 2026 · inaugural annual
- نسخه
- v1.0.0 · draft for stewardship review
- Publication ID
- NR-XTECH-MATERIALS-GLOBAL-2026-BASELINE-v1.0.0
- بستن شواهد
- 30 September 2026
- Publication date
- اکتبر 2026
- DOI
- concept and version DOI at deposit
ناشر
- ناشر ثبتشده
- The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI), for the Nexus Consortium
- مکان
- Toronto
- ویراستار
- Saeed Valadbaygi, Chief Steward and Managing Editor
- متولیان
- GCRI · technical truth · the Global Risks Forum (GRF) · public meaning · the Global Risks Alliance (GRA) · capital meaning
- پروانه
- text CC BY 4.0; data on the terms of each source
- Copyright
- © 2026 GCRI · Nexus Consortium
- زبان
- English (en-GB) source edition
- Correspondence
- Registry correction pathway · editorial office
Colophon
- قالب
- A4 portrait · screen, print and archival PDF
- Typefaces
- Space Grotesk (display) · Geist (text) · IBM Plex Sans Italic (standfirsts) · IBM Plex Mono (data)
- Design standard
- Reports Foundational Edition, Volume I, Part VII
- دسترسپذیری
- tagged PDF and HTML targets; text alternatives for every figure
- تولید
- Reports editorial team, GCRI
Release path for this version
| گام | آنچه رخ میدهد | زمان |
|---|---|---|
| پیشنویس | editorial self-check complete at evidence close | اکتبر 2026 |
| Steward review | five passes on the exact draft (keys T · M · F · N) | Q4 2026 |
| تأیید | publication authority approves the exact digest | before release |
| Deposit | concept and version DOI minted; registry pointer set | at release |
| جانشینی | the 2027 materials edition reports changes against this baseline | 2027 |
- Current version
- v1.0.0 draft, stewardship review
- Previous edition
- none, first edition of the series
- Next edition
- NR-XTECH-MATERIALS-GLOBAL-2027-v1.0.0
- Latest version
- resolve the concept DOI or the registry record
- Correction route
- Registry correction pathway
- Notice types
- erratum · addendum · supersession · withdrawal
C.3سیاههٔ اصلاحات
0correction notices. No edition has been released yet, so none can be corrected; the log below lists each edition’s current version.
| ویراست | نسخه | تاریخ | وضعیت | تغییر | Notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| XT-12 | NR-XTECH-MATERIALS-GLOBAL-2026-BASELINE-v1.0.0 | اکتبر 2026 | پیشنویس | Baseline Edition 2026, inaugural annual edition, | هیچ |
Notice types: erratum, addendum, supersession, withdrawal. A correction is a new version with a published notice; the earlier version stays resolvable, and no edition is ever edited in silence.
C.4Open record
This edition’s open record
- Publication ID
- NR-XTECH-MATERIALS-GLOBAL-2026-BASELINE-v1.0.0
- Desk identifier and series alias
- NR-GCRI-XT-12-2026-BASELINE-v1.0.0 · NR-XTC-XT-12-2026-BL
- Collection
- NR-COL-2026-BASELINE (IsPartOf at deposit)
- DOI
- Concept and version DOI at deposit, on Zenodo with DataCite metadata
- Versions
- Each correction is a new version (isNewVersionOf); the concept DOI resolves to the latest
- Bundle
- RO-Crate 1.2 with CITATION.cff, CodeMeta and PROV-O provenance; a signed manifest
- پروانه
- CC BY 4.0 (SPDX CC-BY-4.0) for original material; metadata CC0 1.0
Credit and identity
- ORCID
- Your iD in the deposit and the contribution record; DataCite can then add the work to your ORCID record
- ROR
- Your organisation by its ROR identifier, never by a typed name alone
- CRediT
- Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Software, Validation, Visualisation, Writing, review and editing
- حساب
- None needed to contribute; never a password
Find and follow
Search the open indexes for Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology; software is cited by its SWHID from Software Heritage, and a quantified scenario run is preregistered on OSF before it is run. Annotation is your choice: Hypothesis opens this page in its own viewer.
Mirrors and harvest
The DOI is canonical. At release each signed bundle is also given an IPFS content identifier and a bloxberg anchor as mirrors; both are listed in the record once they exist. Zenodo exposes every record over OAI-PMH, and reviews and endorsements can arrive through COAR Notify where the repository supports it.
{
"metadata": {
"resource_type": {
"id": "dataset"
},
"title": "Evidence on Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology for Nexus Reports",
"publication_date": "YYYY-MM-DD",
"creators": [
{
"person_or_org": {
"type": "personal",
"family_name": "Your family name",
"given_name": "Your given name",
"identifiers": [
{
"scheme": "orcid",
"identifier": "0000-0000-0000-0000"
}
]
},
"affiliations": [
{
"id": "ROR identifier of your organisation"
}
]
}
],
"description": "What it is, where its record is kept and how it bears on Exponential Technology Report 2026: Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology.",
"rights": [
{
"id": "cc-by-4.0"
}
],
"subjects": [
{
"subject": "Nexus Reports"
},
{
"subject": "Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology"
},
{
"subject": "Exponential Technology Report · XT-12"
}
],
"related_identifiers": [
{
"identifier": "https://therisk.global/nexus-reports/editions/xt-12/",
"scheme": "url",
"relation_type": {
"id": "issupplementto"
},
"resource_type": {
"id": "publication-report"
}
}
],
"version": "1.0.0"
},
"custom_fields": {},
"access": {
"record": "public",
"files": "public"
},
"files": {
"enabled": true
},
"parent": {
"communities": {
"default": "nexusreports"
}
}
}C.5Where this edition sits among the six pillars
Foundry seals the evidence and Universe tests it; Reports publishes it; Standards takes its corrections and Academy teaches from it.
- F03 Sealed observations and indicator series Foundry Sealed observations and indicator series behind a profile (closeout).
- F04 After-action and scenario findings for Universe After-action and scenario findings for chapters 10 and 13 (after action review).
- F05 National Portfolio movement for chapter Foundry National Portfolio movement for chapter 11 (after action review).
- Applied in editions Standards Nexus Standards: applied in editions.
- XT-12 edition Reports Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology 2026, published in every format with its sources, citation and corrections.
- F06 Method and correction findings as change Standards Method and correction findings as change proposals (correction).
- F12 Q4 synthesis informs the next-year Universe Q4 synthesis informs the next-year mandate (renewal).
- Taught in the open Academy Risk Academy: taught in the open.
What Foundry and Universe hand to this edition, and what it hands to Standards, Universe and Academy. From the programme spine; XT-12 is a drafted Baseline Edition, so these handoffs run from its first operational quarter.
| تحویل | Between | What crosses, and when |
|---|---|---|
| F03 | Foundry to Reports | Sealed observations and indicator series behind a profile (closeout). |
| F04 | Universe to Reports | After-action and scenario findings for chapters 10 and 13 (after action review). |
| F05 | Foundry to Reports | National Portfolio movement for chapter 11 (after action review). |
| Ring | Nexus Standards to Reports | Nexus Standards: applied in editions. |
| F06 | Reports to Nexus Standards | Method and correction findings as change proposals (correction). |
| F12 | Reports to Universe | Q4 synthesis informs the next-year mandate (renewal). |
| Ring | Reports to Risk Academy | Risk Academy: taught in the open. |