Skip to content

GCRI · Reports

Scenarios and methods

Scenarios and methods reports set out the analytical machinery behind the series: scenario frameworks, models, statistical methods and the assumptions that drive them. A scenario is a coherent account of a possible future, not a prediction, and its value depends on whether readers can see and test what went into it. This page sets out how analytical studies are documented, reviewed and reproduced, and how their uncertainty is stated.

02Pirs

Scenarios and methods: how the risk develops.

Transparent analytical studies. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

Mekanîzma

Hidden assumptions

Discount rates, baselines, elasticities and exposure data can drive results more than the model does. When assumptions sit in code rather than in the text, reviewers cannot test what matters most.

Mekanîzma

Scenarios read as forecasts

Illustrative pathways are quoted as expected outcomes, and a middle scenario is read as most likely. Without stated purpose and plausibility, scenario results become false predictions in decision documents.

Mekanîzma

Model lineage

Models are reused and extended across studies, so an error in a shared component or dataset propagates into every study built on it. Version identifiers make that lineage traceable.

Mekanîzma

Reproduction is rarely tried

Code and data may be available yet never rerun by anyone else. Without independent reproduction, errors in implementation can persist through review and into the reports that cite the results.

03Çavdêrî bike

Series production desk.

Ekrana ku tîmek dê ji bo şopandina vê mijarê bikar bîne: pîvan, rewş û biryarên wê. Nav mînak in û nirx nîşander in.

Series production desk

Scenarios and methods · Annual synthesis · Edition 9

Data check behind planGCRI · Reports

Editions in production

Senteza salaneGerdûnîData check75W13
Country profile 7WelatPeer review99W32
Water outlookSectoralNivîsandin50W15
Methods note 4RêbazHatiye weşandin100qediya

Data check, annual synthesis

Values traced, %88 of 100 requiredLabels attached, %87 of 100 requiredUncertainty stated, %90 of 100 required

Edition pipeline

  1. Planlijne
  2. Draftauthors
  3. Data checkevery value
  4. Peer reviewtwo rounds
  5. Editorialdecision
  6. WeşanDOI
  7. Rastkirinbi guhertoyan
Series production desk: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Scenarios and methods.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.
04In the five domains

Scenario and methods editions serve every domain’s analysts.

Methods follow reporting guides such as PRISMA 2020 for reviews; scenario results are never presented as forecasts. Models carry NS-12 cards.

  • Methods papers.
  • Scenario critiques.
05Simulator

Stok, herik, dereng û sînorê guherînê.

Du stok, zext û kapasîteya adaptasyonê, bi xelekeyeke mezinbûnê ya xurtker, bersiveke hevsengiyê ya dereng û zirarê dema ku zext ji kapasîteyê derbas dibe têne girêdan; li derveyî sînor pergal dikare biguhere. Modela fêrkirinê bi nirxên nimûneyî yên diyarkirî, ne pêşbînî.

Kontrol

Zêdebûna zextê
6.0% salê
Bandora kapasîteyê di kêmkirina zextê de
4.0% salê
Bersiva veberhênanê li hember zextê ya hatî dîtin
20%
Derengiya têgihîştinê
4.0 sal
Sînorê guherînê yê zextê
60 indeks
Zêdebûn li derveyî sînor
2.0 carî
Salên simulekirî
50 sal

Xwendin

Zexta herî bilind
113 nîşander
Kapasîte di dawiyê de
186 indeks
Salên li ser sînor
15.8 sal
Jimar, rêbaz û çavkanî
SalZextêKapasîteHatî dîtin
020.050.020.0
423.344.921.2
827.242.224.0
1231.742.327.7
1636.845.532.2
2042.351.537.2
2447.960.342.6
2853.271.348.0
3257.884.353.1
3666.498.458.4
4082.7115.969.7
4497.8139.783.8
48109.1169.497.3

Rêbaz

  1. System dynamics Forrester (1961), Industrial Dynamics, MIT Press; Sterman (2000), Business Dynamics
  2. Critical transitions and tipping points Scheffer and others (2009), Early-warning signals for critical transitions, Nature 461
  3. Causal loop diagram Sterman (2000), Business Dynamics, McGraw-Hill
  4. Uncertainty fan (parameter Monte Carlo) Spiegelhalter, Pearson and Short (2011), Visualising uncertainty about the future, Science 333
  5. One-at-a-time sensitivity (tornado) Saltelli and others (2008), Global Sensitivity Analysis: The Primer, Wiley

Dane

No observed data enters this model: it runs on the teaching values set by the controls, to be replaced with a programme’s own evidence.

Stok, herik, derengî û sînorekî tipping. Modeleke hînkirinê ya ronîker: li gorî nirxên ku kontrol destnîşan dikin dixebite, ne li ser daneyên pîvandî. Rêbaz: Dînamîkên pergalê (Forrester (1961), Industrial Dynamics, MIT Press; Sterman (2000), Business Dynamics); Veguherînên krîtîk û xalên tipping (Scheffer û yên din (2009), Early-warning signals for critical transitions, Nature 461); Dîagrama xelekên sedemî (Sterman (2000), Business Dynamics, McGraw-Hill).

Li seranserê şeş stûnan, bi pêşengiya Nexus Consortium

06Nîşander

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

NîşaneYekîneRîtmSource typeNîşan
Studies with archived code and datapercent of studiesper versionRepository deposit recordsÇAVDÊRÎKIRÎ
Assumptions documented in an assumptions registerpercent of key parametersper studyEditorial auditHATIYE RAPORKIRIN
Independent reproduction statuscategory: not attempted, partial, fullper studyReproduction recordHATIYE RAPORKIRIN
Sensitivity analyses reported for key parameterspercent of key parametersper studyEditorial auditHATIYE RAPORKIRIN
Model and dataset versions cited with identifierspercent of model and data citationsper versionReference metadataÇAVDÊRÎKIRÎ
Statistical or methods review completedyes or no, with reviewer roleper studyReview recordDECLARED
07Rêbaz û delîl

How scenarios and methods is modelled, measured and tested.

Model, texmînên wî, daneyên wî û nediyariya wî, bi şeweyê ku zanyar an endezyar kontrol bike. Avahî rêbazên weşandî dişopînin. Nirxên hatine xêzkirin nimûneyî ne, ne encam in.

Model, hevkêşe û texmîn

The model structure used for scenarios and methods, the assumptions it makes and how each is tested.

Xetera hêmana iRi = f(Hi, Ei, Vi, Ci)metirsî, rûbirûbûn, lawazî û kapasîteya serederiyê
Windahiya salane ya hêvîkirîEAL = ∑k pk · Lkover events k with annual probability pk
Pergalên girêdayîxt+1 = A xt + B ut + εtA carries the couplings, u the shock, ε the error
TexmînÇima tê çêkirinÇawa tê ceribandin
Metirsî û rûbirûbûn di nav bûyerekê de serbixwe neEntegrala windahiyê ji hesabkirinê re maqûl dihêleBi lihevhatineke copula li ser tomarên hevbeş re bidin ber hev
Girêdan li nêzî xala xebatê xêzik inDihêle şok di A de belav bibinJi derveyî rêza xêzik tevlihev bike û bide ber hev
Xêzên lawaziyê di navbera cihan de têne veguhastinXêzikên herêmî kêm tên dîtinLi hember windahiyên çavdêrîkirî erê bike li cihê ku hene
Têketin
danehevên bi guhertoyan û çavkaniyê
Derketin
belavkirin, tu carî jimarên tenê
Kod
bi qerta modelê û ceribandinan re hat weşandin
Zêdebûn
heman dane, kod, jîngeh û tov
Formulasyonên standard ên xetereyê û qada rewşê; texmînên navborî ji bo rêbazê tîpîk in, ji bo nirxandinê hatine diyarkirin, ne encam in.
FAIR guiding principles · GO FAIR and FORCE11W3C PROV · World Wide Web ConsortiumGuidance on consistent treatment of uncertainties · IPCCCEOS Analysis Ready Data · Committee on Earth Observation Satellites
08Çavkanî

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

ÇavkanîWhat it givesLicence class
AR6 Scenarios Database (IAMC and IIASA)Integrated assessment scenarios assessed by the IPCC with metadataFree with registration, terms per IIASA
SSP Database (IIASA)Shared Socioeconomic Pathway projections of population, economy and emissionsFree with registration, terms per IIASA
NGFS climate scenariosClimate-related financial scenarios with documentationFree to use, terms per NGFS
ZenodoArchived code, data and model versions with DOIsMetadata CC0, licence per record
Software HeritageArchived source code with intrinsic identifiersCode under its own licence
OSF RegistriesPre-registered analysis plans and study protocolsMetadata CC0, licence per registration
09Biryar

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

Reports prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

Kî biryarê didePirsEvidence this page serves
Bankên navendî û çavdêrên darayîWhich scenario sets are fit for climate and systemic stress testingScenario documentation, assumptions and sensitivity of results
Planning and environment ministriesHow to use scenario results in national plans without reading them as forecastsStated scenario purpose and the range across scenarios
Statistical and methods review panelsWhether a method is adequately documented and reproducibleAssumptions registers, archived code and reproduction records
Research fundersWhether to require code, data and reproduction for funded analytical workArchive and reproduction indicators across studies

Outputs this topic produces

  • Method reports with assumptions registers and sensitivity analyses
  • Archived code and data with persistent identifiers
  • Scenario descriptions stating purpose, framing and plausibility
  • Reproduction records from independent reruns
10Core questions

What the series asks.

Findings are only as reliable as the methods behind them. Scenario studies and stress tests are powerful tools for exploring plausible futures and testing resilience, but they are easily misread as predictions or as verdicts on institutions. Publishing methods in full, with their assumptions and validation, lets readers judge what a result means and lets other researchers reproduce or challenge it.

  • Which assumptions drive a scenario’s results, and how sensitive are the conclusions to them?
  • Has the model been validated against historical events or independent data, and with what result?
  • How are uncertainties combined and communicated, including deep uncertainty that cannot be quantified?
  • Can another team reproduce the result from the published data and code?
11Çarçove

What the series covers.

Two series publish analysis and the methods behind it.

Senaryo

Plausible futures

Narrative and quantitative scenarios that explore how systems could evolve under stated assumptions.

Stress tests

Severe but plausible shocks

Tests of how systems respond to defined shocks; they describe systems, not the soundness of any firm.

Rêbaz

Technical notes

Model documentation, data pipelines and validation reports for reuse and review.

Good scenario practice distinguishes between exploratory scenarios, which map a range of plausible futures, and stress scenarios, which test a system against a severe but plausible shock. Both are useful, and both are misused when a single path is presented as the expected outcome. Editions therefore present sets of scenarios with their driving assumptions and show where results diverge.

12How editions are built

How editions are built, and their limits.

  1. 01

    Model documentation

    Purpose, structure, inputs, assumptions and known limits, published alongside results.

  2. 02

    Erêkirin

    Back-testing, comparison with independent data and sensitivity analysis, using uncertainty quantification and model validation.

  3. 03

    Reproducibility

    Data and code released where rights permit, with pipelines documented under data engineering, interoperability and stewardship.

  4. 04

    Communication

    Results labelled Scenario, Modelled or Forecast, with ranges rather than single numbers where uncertainty is material.

13Rêbaz

How it is studied, and what the methods cannot say.

  1. Uncertainty quantification and model validationCalibrated language in assessments · Certainty of evidence ratingsApplied here
  2. Probability and statisticsMeta-analysis with heterogeneity stated · Small-study and publication biasApplied here
  3. Data engineering, interoperability and stewardshipStructured publishing in JATS XML · Persistent identifiers across the recordApplied here
14Where this page’s references

Where this page’s references lead.

Sazî û belgeyên ku ev rûpel li hember wan tê xwendin. Rewş û çap diguherin; her girêdan diçe ba saziya derxistinê.

15Pirs

Pirs û bersiv.

Is a scenario a forecast?
No. A scenario is a coherent and plausible description of a possible future used to explore consequences and decisions. It carries no probability unless one is explicitly and defensibly assigned.
What is the difference between reproduction and replication?
Reproduction reruns the same code on the same data to obtain the same result. Replication tests the finding with new data or methods. Both matter; they answer different questions.
Why publish an assumptions register?
Because results often depend more on a few assumptions than on the model structure. A register lets reviewers and users test the assumptions that drive the result.
Is a scenario a prediction?
No. A scenario explores what could happen under stated assumptions. It is labelled Scenario and should not be read as a forecast.
Are the stress tests regulatory stress tests?
No. They are research studies of how systems respond to shocks, and they make no finding about the soundness of any institution.
Can I reuse the models?
Where rights permit, code and data are released with a licence stated in the source and rights register.
What if a method is found to be flawed?
The method note and every edition that relied on it are corrected in new versions, with the change recorded on the corrections page.
rêzeya Pergalên StratejîkTevkarî bike

Ji vê rûpelê delîl bidin.

Reports weşana sê mehane ya Konsorsiyûmê ye. Tiştê ku tu li ser vê mijarê dizanî dikare di çapa pêş de bibe delîl, dosya an rastkirin, bi navê te û di bin CC BY 4.0 de weşandî li cihê ku karê te bi xwe be.

GCRIrêzeya Pergalên StratejîkXetera pergalên gerdûnî û berxwedanXetera pergalan û berxwedana welatanWelat, sê mehane
rêzeya Pergalên Stratejîk

Rêbazek, danehevek an pirsek bîne.

Agahî û pirs îro vekirî ne. Pirsek referansekê distîne û gava piştî wê dide nasîn; serlêdan, drav, veqetandina hesabkirinê û tomarkirin tenê dema ku tîm, mercên wê û kapasîteya vekolînê hebin vedibin.