Skip to content

GCRI · Inovasi dan perubahan teknologi

Penilaian teknologi

Claims about technology are easy to make and hard to check. Technology assessment at The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI) asks what a technology actually does, under which conditions, on what evidence and with what limits. Institutions can then tell a demonstration from a dependable capability before they adopt, procure or regulate. Part of innovation and technological change.

01Ruang kerja

The workspace for technology assessment.

Jalur inovasi

GCRI · Gerbang tahap · Antarmuka contoh, bukan catatan

Gate review in 8 dGCRI · GCRI

Menurut tingkat kesiapan

TRL 2 hingga 301
Siklus tinjauan metodekonsep diuji
TRL 4 hingga 502
Audit label buktivalidasi laboratorium
Pembangunan Model Nasionalvalidasi laboratorium
TRL 6 hingga 701
Perencanaan edisi laporanuji coba dengan pemilik
Tinjauan adopsi01
Desain misi tahunanpemilik memutuskan

Kriteria kesiapan

uji coba vs gerbang

Bukti efek85 of 70 requiredPengaman60 of 80 requiredBiaya operasi diketahui40 dari 60 diwajibkanKomitmen pemilik43 dari 75 yang disyaratkan

Isu uji coba

  1. I-1Lisensi data untuk lokasi uji cobaUntuk diperiksa9 hari
  2. I-2Protokol pengamat ditandatanganiSelesai8 hari
Alur inovasi.Antarmuka ilustratif; bukan data langsung.

GCRI · Alur inovasi. Alur inovasi: nama contoh dan nilai ilustratif, bukan catatan.

02What is examined

Four questions behind every assessment.

A fourth question runs through all three: what would make the technology fail, and has that been looked for?

Kesiapan

How mature is it?

Bukti kematangan dalam kondisi penggunaan yang dituju, bukan dalam kondisi yang paling menguntungkan.

Validasi

Has it been tested?

Pengujian independen terhadap tujuan yang dinyatakan, dengan kondisi pengujian yang dilaporkan.

Claims

Apa persisnya yang diklaim?

Capability statements separated into measured, estimated and asserted.

03Readiness scales

Readiness levels, what they measure and what they leave out.

Technology readiness levels run from one, basic principles observed, to nine, a system proven in its operational environment. NASA introduced them; ISO 16290:2013 defines them for space systems, and many agencies use adapted versions. A readiness level describes maturity in a stated environment. It says nothing about cost, safety in a different setting, social acceptance or whether an organisation can operate the technology.

PertanyaanBukti yang menjawabnyaKesenjangan umum
Does it work as claimed?Pengujian independen terhadap rencana yang didaftarkan sebelumnya, pada data yang ditahan (held-out) atau di lingkungan yang representatifTolok ukur vendor pada data yang menjadi dasar penyetelan sistem
Does it work here?Uji coba dalam konteks sasaran, dengan pengguna dan kondisi setempatTransfer dari iklim, bahasa, atau infrastruktur yang berbeda
What does it depend on?Bills of materials, supply and energy needs, skills requiredHidden dependence on a single supplier or service
Bagaimana ia gagal?Uji adversarial dan uji ketahanan; catatan insidenTesting only the expected cases
04Measurement practice

Melaporkan kapabilitas secara jujur.

  • Report performance with confidence intervals and on the population it will serve, not only on aggregate test sets.
  • Periksa kontaminasi: data uji yang bocor ke dalam data pelatihan menggelembungkan skor, masalah yang sudah dikenal pada tolok ukur AI.
  • For prediction models in health and similar settings, follow reporting guides such as TRIPOD+AI (2024).
  • Separate a demonstration, a pilot and sustained operation; each is a different claim.

The OECD’s Framework for Anticipatory Governance of Emerging Technologies of 2024 and parliamentary technology assessment offices, networked through EPTA, provide models of assessment that look beyond performance to values and institutions.

05GCRI’s part

Assessment reports, not approvals.

An assessment records what was tested, how and with what result. It confers no status and is never a condition of procurement. Assessments are designed for the Labs Evidence series and, when they concern readiness for national deployment, the Foundry Build and Readiness series; evidence would follow NS-11 of the proposed Nexus Standards. Providers can submit test plans; independent researchers can submit replications.

06Measurement rules

How capability is reported.

  • Measured capability is published with workload, data size, hardware, configuration, software version and interval
  • Peak, sustained, available and allocated capacity are reported separately
  • Jumlah perangkat dan spesifikasi merupakan deskriptor, bukan hasil penerapan
  • Penggunaan energi, pendinginan, dan air dipantau, dengan pengukuran dipisahkan dari estimasi
  • Kegagalan dan keterbatasan yang ditemukan selama pengujian dilaporkan, bukan dihapus
07How tests run

Dari rencana evaluasi hingga hasil yang tercatat.

  1. 01

    Rencana evaluasi

    Tujuan, metrik, kondisi, dan aturan penghentian yang disepakati sebelum pengujian.

  2. 02

    Uji terkendali

    Experiments in Labs test environments or the annual Universe programme, with independent observation.

  3. 03

    Hasil tercatat

    Results with their method, limits and evidence label, published where rights allow.

08Batas wilayah

Testing is not certification.

An assessment describes what was tested and found. It is not accreditation, certification, endorsement or approval for use. Evaluation never depends on a provider’s contribution. Providers start at technology and infrastructure providers. See also responsible technology and the Labs Evidence report series.

10Pertanyaan

Tanya jawab.

Dapatkah vendor mengutip penilaian GCRI dalam pemasaran?
Only as a factual citation of the published result, with its scope and limits, and never as certification or endorsement. Misrepresentation can be reported to the integrity address.
Siapa yang membayar sebuah asesmen?
Terms are set out for each testbed call or agreement. Payment never buys a result, and evaluation never depends on a high contribution.
Are negative results published?
Yes, where rights allow. A technology that fails a test produces a result as valid as one that passes.
Apakah GCRI menggunakan tingkat kesiapan?
Readiness is described with evidence for the specific setting. Where a recognised readiness scale is referenced, it is named and the evidence for the level is shown.
Dapatkah suatu penilaian disanggah?
Ya. Penyedia, peneliti, dan masyarakat dapat menyanggah sebuah penilaian yang telah diterbitkan melalui jalur integritas. Koreksi yang diterima menghasilkan versi baru yang tercatat beserta riwayatnya.
LaporanBerkontribusi

Kontribusikan bukti dari halaman ini.

Reports adalah publikasi triwulanan Konsorsium. Apa yang Anda ketahui tentang subjek ini dapat menjadi bukti, kasus, atau koreksi dalam edisi berikutnya, dengan kredit atas nama Anda dan dipublikasikan di bawah CC BY 4.0 jika merupakan karya Anda sendiri.

GCRI
Global Centre for Risk and Innovation

Bawa metode, dataset, atau pertanyaan.

Informasi dan pertanyaan sudah terbuka hari ini. Sebuah pertanyaan menerima nomor referensi dan menyebutkan langkah berikutnya; lamaran, pembayaran, alokasi komputasi, dan pendaftaran hanya dibuka ketika tim, ketentuan, dan kapasitas tinjauannya tersedia.