Skip to content

GCRI · Наука и методы

Модели и сценарии

Models explore what could happen when the real experiment is impossible: a flood spreading through a city, a grid in a heatwave, a price shock moving through food systems. Scenarios set out plausible futures to test against. The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI) states each model’s validation, assumptions and uncertainty, and never presents an output as an observation. Part of science and methods.

02Four disciplines

What every GCRI model must show.

A model is only as useful as its user’s understanding of where it holds. These four elements are published with every model result.

Валидация

Tested against reality

Compared with observations it was not built on, using uncertainty quantification and model validation.

Допущения

Stated, not hidden

Every key assumption is written down, with how results change if it is wrong.

Неопределённость

Диапазоны, а не отдельные числа

Results are reported with ranges and the sources of uncertainty that drive them.

03Семейства сценариев

The scenario frameworks most risk analyses are read against.

СистемаТекст и датаЧто это даётПредупреждение
Shared Socioeconomic Pathways with CMIP6 forcing (ScenarioMIP)Research community, O’Neill and others, 2016Population, economy and emissions storylines paired with climate model runsSome high-emission pathways are now considered less plausible; state why one is chosen
База данных сценариев Шестого оценочного доклада МГЭИК (AR6)IPCC Working Group III, 2022Mitigation pathways classed by warming outcomeТраектория не является ни планом, ни прогнозом
NGFS climate scenarios, Phase VNetwork for Greening the Financial System, 2024Transition and physical risk scenarios for financial supervisionDesigned for finance; physical damage functions are coarse
National and sector storylinesМинистерства, ведомства и операторыLocally coherent stress casesMust be checked for internal physical and economic consistency
04Calibration and validation

How a model earns trust, and the documentation that shows it.

ПрактикаСправкаWhat it guards against
Bayesian calibration with model discrepancyKennedy and O’Hagan, 2001Tuning parameters to hide a structural error
Глобальный уровень анализа чувствительностиSaltelli and others, 2020, among the five rules for models that serve societyТочность отчётности, которую входные данные обеспечить не могут
Out-of-sample and hindcast testsСтандарт в гидрологии и климатическом моделированииМодель, которая соответствует прошлому, но не способна прогнозировать
Протокол ODD для агентно-ориентированных моделейGrimm and others, 2020Simulations that no one else can understand or rebuild
Model cardsMitchell and others, 2019Using a model outside the conditions it was evaluated for
05GCRI’s part

Documented models, published as scenario or modelled evidence.

GCRI builds and tests models with national teams and publishes them with their documentation, so another team can rerun or challenge them. Model results never stand in for observation and never become a decision. Reviewed scenario work is designed for the Scenario and Stress-Test series and the Foresight Outlook series; each model would carry a card under NS-12 of the proposed Nexus Standards. Modellers can contribute validation datasets, intercomparison runs and documented failure cases.

06Контрфактические сценарии

Asking what would have happened otherwise.

Many risk and policy questions are counterfactual: what losses a flood defence prevented, or how a programme changed outcomes. GCRI answers them with causal inference and impact evaluation. It states the identifying assumptions. It says so when the data cannot support an answer.

07Сценарии

Правдоподобные варианты будущего, а не предсказания.

  1. 01

    Цель

    Сценарии позволяют проверить решения на широком спектре правдоподобных условий, включая суровые.

  2. 02

    Проектирование

    Built with scenario design and stress testing, with drivers and storylines stated.

  3. 03

    Интерпретация

    Simulated loss or performance is not observed impact, and a scenario carries no probability unless one is estimated and shown.

  4. 04

    Использовать

    Scenario results inform options for competent decision-makers. Analysis is not the decision.

08Where models run

Systems, reports and related pages.

Сценарии, варианты и анализ решений выполняются в NXS-DSS (дела по решениям и обсуждение). Рецензированные работы по сценариям публикуются в серии «Сценарии и стресс-тесты». Общие методы моделирования организованы через платформу «Системная наука и моделирование». См. также науку о рисках.

Model code, data and parameters are recorded so results can be reproduced, within the rights of each source.

10Вопросы

Вопросы и ответы.

Why should anyone trust a model?
Trust should follow evidence: validation against independent data, clear assumptions, honest uncertainty and openness to challenge. GCRI publishes all four with each model result.
What is the difference between a forecast and a scenario?
A forecast estimates what is likely to happen over a period with a measurable skill. A scenario describes a plausible situation to test decisions against, without claiming it will happen.
Can I see the model code?
Where licences and security allow, code and parameters are released with the publication. Where they cannot be released, the method is described in enough detail to be assessed.
Как исправляются ошибки моделей?
Through the same correction process as any publication. An error found after release leads to a new recorded version and, where needed, revised results.
Does GCRI use AI models?
Where machine learning is used, it is validated and reported like any other model, with its training data, performance on unseen cases and known failure modes.
ОтчётыВнести вклад

Поделитесь доказательствами с этой страницы.

Reports является ежеквартальным изданием Консорциума. Ваши знания по этой теме могут стать доказательством, кейсом или исправлением в следующем выпуске с указанием вашего авторства и публикацией по лицензии CC BY 4.0, если это ваша собственная работа.

GCRI
Global Centre for Risk and Innovation

Предложите метод, набор данных или вопрос.

Информация и запросы открыты уже сегодня. Запрос получает номер и указывает следующий шаг; заявки, платежи, выделение вычислительных ресурсов и регистрации открываются только тогда, когда существуют их команда, условия и возможности для проверки.

Правовая информация

Карты, данные и рисунки на этом сайте приводятся для контекста и общей информации. Они не являются советом, прогнозом или предупреждением; ограничения информации изложены в Оговорках и уведомлениях о данных.