Skip to content

GCRI · 과학 및 방법

모델과 시나리오

Models explore what could happen when the real experiment is impossible: a flood spreading through a city, a grid in a heatwave, a price shock moving through food systems. Scenarios set out plausible futures to test against. The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI) states each model’s validation, assumptions and uncertainty, and never presents an output as an observation. Part of science and methods.

02Four disciplines

What every GCRI model must show.

A model is only as useful as its user’s understanding of where it holds. These four elements are published with every model result.

검증

Tested against reality

Compared with observations it was not built on, using uncertainty quantification and model validation.

가정

숨기지 않고 명시함

Every key assumption is written down, with how results change if it is wrong.

불확실성

Ranges, not single numbers

Results are reported with ranges and the sources of uncertainty that drive them.

03시나리오 계열

The scenario frameworks most risk analyses are read against.

프레임워크기관과 날짜제공 내용주의
Shared Socioeconomic Pathways with CMIP6 forcing (ScenarioMIP)Research community, O’Neill and others, 2016Population, economy and emissions storylines paired with climate model runs일부 고배출 경로는 이제 개연성이 낮은 것으로 간주되므로 선택 사유를 명시해야 함
IPCC AR6 시나리오 데이터베이스IPCC Working Group III, 2022Mitigation pathways classed by warming outcomeA pathway is not a plan or a forecast
NGFS 기후 시나리오, 5단계Network for Greening the Financial System, 2024금융 감독을 위한 전환 리스크 및 물리적 리스크 시나리오금융용으로 설계되어 물리적 피해 함수는 거칩니다
National and sector storylinesMinistries, agencies and operatorsLocally coherent stress casesMust be checked for internal physical and economic consistency
04Calibration and validation

How a model earns trust, and the documentation that shows it.

실무참조 번호What it guards against
Bayesian calibration with model discrepancyKennedy and O’Hagan, 2001Tuning parameters to hide a structural error
글로벌 민감도 분석Saltelli 외, 2020, 사회에 기여하는 모델을 위한 다섯 가지 규칙 중입력 자료가 뒷받침할 수 없는 보고 정밀도
Out-of-sample and hindcast testsStandard in hydrology and climate modelling과거에는 들어맞지만 예측하지 못하는 모델
ODD protocol for agent-based modelsGrimm and others, 2020Simulations that no one else can understand or rebuild
Model cardsMitchell and others, 2019Using a model outside the conditions it was evaluated for
05GCRI’s part

Documented models, published as scenario or modelled evidence.

GCRI builds and tests models with national teams and publishes them with their documentation, so another team can rerun or challenge them. Model results never stand in for observation and never become a decision. Reviewed scenario work is designed for the Scenario and Stress-Test series and the Foresight Outlook series; each model would carry a card under NS-12 of the proposed Nexus Standards. Modellers can contribute validation datasets, intercomparison runs and documented failure cases.

06Counterfactuals

Asking what would have happened otherwise.

Many risk and policy questions are counterfactual: what losses a flood defence prevented, or how a programme changed outcomes. GCRI answers them with causal inference and impact evaluation. It states the identifying assumptions. It says so when the data cannot support an answer.

07시나리오

예측이 아닌, 개연성 있는 미래.

  1. 01

    목적

    Scenarios test decisions against a range of plausible conditions, including severe ones.

  2. 02

    설계

    Built with scenario design and stress testing, with drivers and storylines stated.

  3. 03

    Interpretation

    Simulated loss or performance is not observed impact, and a scenario carries no probability unless one is estimated and shown.

  4. 04

    활용

    시나리오 결과는 권한 있는 의사결정자가 선택지를 검토하는 데 활용됩니다. 분석이 곧 결정은 아닙니다.

08Where models run

Systems, reports and related pages.

Scenarios, options and decision analysis run in NXS-DSS (decision cases and deliberation). Reviewed scenario work is published in the Scenario and Stress-Test series. Shared modelling methods are organised through the Systems Science and Modelling platform. See also risk science.

Model code, data and parameters are recorded so results can be reproduced, within the rights of each source.

10질문

질문과 답변.

Why should anyone trust a model?
Trust should follow evidence: validation against independent data, clear assumptions, honest uncertainty and openness to challenge. GCRI publishes all four with each model result.
What is the difference between a forecast and a scenario?
예측은 측정 가능한 숙련도를 바탕으로 일정 기간 동안 일어날 가능성이 높은 일을 추정합니다. 시나리오는 의사결정을 시험해 볼 수 있는 그럴듯한 상황을 서술하며, 그 상황이 실제로 일어난다고 주장하지 않습니다.
Can I see the model code?
Where licences and security allow, code and parameters are released with the publication. Where they cannot be released, the method is described in enough detail to be assessed.
How are model errors corrected?
다른 모든 간행물과 동일한 정정 절차를 따릅니다. 공개 후 오류가 발견되면 새로운 기록 버전이 만들어지며, 필요한 경우 결과도 수정됩니다.
Does GCRI use AI models?
Where machine learning is used, it is validated and reported like any other model, with its training data, performance on unseen cases and known failure modes.
보고서기여하기

이 페이지에서 증거를 기여하십시오.

Reports는 컨소시엄의 분기별 간행물입니다. 이 주제에 관해 귀하가 아는 것은 다음 호에서 근거, 사례 또는 정정이 될 수 있으며, 귀하의 이름으로 표시되고, 귀하 자신의 저작인 경우 CC BY 4.0으로 발행됩니다.

GCRI
글로벌 리스크 혁신 센터(Global Centre for Risk and Innovation)

방법, 데이터세트 또는 질문을 가져오십시오.

정보와 문의는 오늘부터 열려 있습니다. 문의에는 참조 번호가 부여되고 다음 단계가 안내됩니다. 신청, 결제, 컴퓨팅 할당, 등록은 해당 팀, 약관, 심사 역량이 갖추어졌을 때만 열립니다.