Skip to content

GCRI · 科学与方法

模型与情景

Models explore what could happen when the real experiment is impossible: a flood spreading through a city, a grid in a heatwave, a price shock moving through food systems. Scenarios set out plausible futures to test against. The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI) states each model’s validation, assumptions and uncertainty, and never presents an output as an observation. Part of science and methods.

02四个学科

每个 GCRI 模型必须展示的内容。

A model is only as useful as its user’s understanding of where it holds. These four elements are published with every model result.

验证

Tested against reality

使用 不确定性量化与模型验证.

假设

Stated, not hidden

Every key assumption is written down, with how results change if it is wrong.

不确定性

给出区间,而非单一数字

结果连同区间及驱动区间的不确定性来源一并报告。

03情景类别

大多数风险分析所参照的情景框架。

框架机构与日期提供的内容注意
采用 CMIP6 强迫的共享社会经济路径(ScenarioMIP)Research community, O’Neill and others, 2016Population, economy and emissions storylines paired with climate model runs一些高排放路径目前被认为可能性较低;须说明选择某一路径的理由
IPCC AR6 情景数据库IPCC Working Group III, 2022Mitigation pathways classed by warming outcome路径不是计划,也不是预测
NGFS 气候情景,第五阶段绿色金融体系网络(Network for Greening the Financial System),2024 年Transition and physical risk scenarios for financial supervision为金融而设计;物理损害函数较为粗略
国家和部门情景叙事部委、机构和运营方局部一致的压力情景Must be checked for internal physical and economic consistency
04校准与验证

模型如何赢得信任,以及体现这一点的文档。

实践编号它所防范的内容
含模型差异的贝叶斯校准Kennedy and O’Hagan, 2001通过调整参数来掩盖结构性错误
全球 敏感性分析Saltelli 等人,2020年,服务社会的模型五项规则之一输入数据无法支撑的报告精度
Out-of-sample and hindcast testsStandard in hydrology and climate modelling拟合过去却无法预测的模型
基于主体的模型的 ODD 协议Grimm and others, 2020Simulations that no one else can understand or rebuild
模型卡Mitchell and others, 2019在评估所针对的条件之外使用模型
05GCRI’s part

有文档记录的模型,作为情景证据或模型证据发布。

GCRI builds and tests models with national teams and publishes them with their documentation, so another team can rerun or challenge them. Model results never stand in for observation and never become a decision. Reviewed scenario work is designed for the Scenario and Stress-Test series and the Foresight Outlook series; each model would carry a card under NS-12 of the proposed Nexus Standards. Modellers can contribute validation datasets, intercomparison runs and documented failure cases.

06反事实

Asking what would have happened otherwise.

许多风险和政策问题是反事实问题:防洪设施避免了多少损失,或某项方案如何改变了结果。GCRI 通过 因果推断与影响评估来回答这些问题。GCRI 会说明识别性假设,并在数据无法支持答案时明确指出。

07情景

是可能的未来,而非预测。

  1. 01

    目的

    情景针对一系列合理情形(包括严重情形)检验决策。

  2. 02

    设计

    Built with scenario design and stress testing, with drivers and storylines stated.

  3. 03

    解读

    模拟的损失或表现并非观测到的影响,除非经过估算并予以展示,否则情景不附带概率。

  4. 04

    使用

    情景结果为有权限的决策者提供选项参考。分析不等于决策。

08模型在哪里运行

系统、报告和相关页面。

Scenarios, options and decision analysis run in NXS-DSS (decision cases and deliberation). Reviewed scenario work is published in the Scenario and Stress-Test series. Shared modelling methods are organised through the Systems Science and Modelling platform. See also risk science.

Model code, data and parameters are recorded so results can be reproduced, within the rights of each source.

10问题

问题与解答。

为什么应当信任一个模型?
Trust should follow evidence: validation against independent data, clear assumptions, honest uncertainty and openness to challenge. GCRI publishes all four with each model result.
What is the difference between a forecast and a scenario?
预测估计某一时期内可能发生的情况,并具有可衡量的预测技巧。情景描述一种可信的情形,用于检验决策,但不声称其将会发生。
我可以查看模型代码吗?
Where licences and security allow, code and parameters are released with the publication. Where they cannot be released, the method is described in enough detail to be assessed.
How are model errors corrected?
通过与任何出版物相同的更正流程。发布后发现的错误将产生新的已记录版本,必要时修订结果。
Does GCRI use AI models?
在使用机器学习之处,与任何其他模型一样对其进行验证和报告,包括训练数据、对未见案例的表现以及已知失效模式。
报告贡献

从本页贡献证据。

Reports 是联合体的季刊。您对该主题的了解可以成为下一期中的证据、案例或更正,署名归您,并在属于您本人作品时以 CC BY 4.0 发布。

GCRI
全球风险与创新中心(The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation)

带来一种方法、一个数据集或一个问题。

信息和咨询现已开放。每项咨询都会获得一个编号,并告知下一步;申请、付款、算力分配和注册只有在相应团队、条款和审查能力就绪时才会开放。