Global Risks Index (GRIx)

Last modified: September 4, 2023
For versions:
Estimated reading time: 32 min

Overview

The Global Risks Index (GRIx) is a cutting-edge framework designed to assess and manage a wide array of risks in an increasingly complex world. Leveraging advanced features like scalable infrastructure, multilateral partnerships, and self-updating algorithms, GRIx offers a comprehensive, adaptable, and user-friendly platform for risk assessment. Its modular design enables customization, allowing organizations across sectors to tailor the framework to their unique needs. Whether it’s tackling global challenges such as climate change and human trafficking or addressing sector-specific risks like cybersecurity and data privacy, GRIx aims to be a one-stop solution. With its focus on continual learning through user feedback loops and data-driven insights, GRIx sets the standard for dynamic and responsive risk management. Stay ahead of the curve and manage risks more effectively with GRIx, the next-generation tool for global risk mitigation.

In an increasingly intricate and interconnected world, the scale and complexity of global risks are mounting at an unprecedented rate. From pandemics and climate change to cyber threats and geopolitical unrest, these challenges present dire threats to the very fabric of human civilization. Characterized by non-linear trajectories, stochastic variability, and intricate interdependencies, these risks are reminiscent of complex systems as described in network theory. The urgency of mitigating these risks is exponentially intensified by rapid technological advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI), Internet of Things (IoT), and blockchain technologies. While these technologies promise transformative solutions, they also engender new forms of risks and vulnerabilities.

  • Stochastic Processes: These are random processes frequently employed in risk modeling, which can account for a wide array of outcomes.
  • Network Theory: A specialized area within graph theory that serves as a powerful tool for modeling the intricate interconnections that characterize global risks.
  • Existential Risks: These are risks with the potential to annihilate human civilization or severely curtail its potential.

Shortcomings of Conventional Risk Management Approaches

The existing risk management frameworks often employ deterministic models and rely heavily on Gaussian or normal distributions. While these approaches are valuable for certain types of risks, they are inadequate for capturing tail risks or black swan events that are becoming increasingly prevalent in the modern landscape. Moreover, conventional frameworks are siloed, failing to integrate a multi-disciplinary perspective that encompasses insights from data science, cognitive science, and risk sciences. They are often predicated on static risk matrices and outdated rule-of-thumb strategies (heuristics), which are not well-equipped for real-time risk assessment or flexible adaptation to fluid situations.

  • Deterministic Models: These models deliver a fixed output for any given input, devoid of any element of randomness.
  • Gaussian Distributions: Also known as normal distributions, these are poor at capturing extreme, unlikely events that have high impacts.
  • Tail Risks: These are the risks associated with extreme events that lie at the fringes of probability distributions.
  • Black Swan Events: These are highly unlikely occurrences that have colossal consequences and are difficult to predict.
  • Heuristics: These are simplified decision-making strategies that, although useful in some contexts, can lead to errors when applied to complex risk environments.

The Imperative for a Next-Gen Framework

Given the urgency of the global risks and the inadequacies of existing frameworks, there’s a pressing need for a more robust, next-generation risk management framework. This is where the Global Risk Index (GRIx) comes into play. GRIx aims to revolutionize risk management by leveraging cutting-edge machine learning algorithms to perform predictive analytics. It incorporates real-time data streams from IoT devices and applies cognitive models to simulate human decision-making processes under conditions of uncertainty.

GRIx employs a Bayesian approach to update risk assessments continuously based on incoming data. In addition, it utilizes neural networks to model the complex interrelationships among various risk factors. What sets GRIx apart is its participatory design, which fosters human-AI collaborations in a multi-agent ecosystem. This approach aligns with the principles of distributed cognition, where cognitive functions are not merely confined to individual agents but are distributed across a network of agents and technological artifacts.

  • Predictive Analytics: The application of data, statistical algorithms, and machine learning to forecast future outcomes.
  • IoT Devices: Devices connected to the Internet that are capable of gathering and exchanging data in real-time.
  • Cognitive Models: Computational frameworks that attempt to replicate human thought processes for better decision-making.
  • Bayesian Approach: A statistical method that integrates prior knowledge along with observed data for probability assessments.
  • Neural Networks: Algorithmic architectures inspired by the human brain, designed to recognize intricate patterns in data.
  • Distributed Cognition: A theoretical framework in which cognitive and intelligent functions are distributed across multiple agents and technological tools in an environment.

The Global Risk Index (GRIx) signifies a monumental shift in risk management paradigms. It offers a technologically sophisticated, scientifically grounded, and participatory model capable of addressing the multifaceted and exigent global risks that humanity confronts today.

Scope

Holistic Risk Evaluation

One cornerstone objective of GRIx is to deliver a holistic assessment of risks, transcending the scope of traditional univariate analyses. The GRIx framework employs sophisticated multivariate statistical methods to dissect and understand the nuanced interactions among a plethora of risk factors. By leveraging cutting-edge machine learning algorithms, such as Random Forests and Support Vector Machines, GRIx aims to apprehend the high-dimensional complexities that underlie various global risks. Beyond numerical data, GRIx also integrates Natural Language Processing (NLP) to scrutinize textual data—such as news coverage, academic reports, and social media posts—for capturing public sentiment and emerging risk trends.

  • Univariate Analyses: In traditional risk management, univariate analyses are commonly used to study individual variables such as the rate of a specific type of cyberattack, the temperature variations in a given location, or the incidence of a particular disease. However, these methods don’t take into account the interactions between different variables, which is often where the most crucial insights into risk lie. Suppose GRIx is assessing the risk of a drought in a specific region. A univariate analysis might only consider annual rainfall data. While this information is valuable, it doesn’t capture other factors like soil moisture levels, deforestation rates, and temperature, which can also significantly influence drought risk.
  • Multivariate Statistical Methods: Multivariate statistical methods allow GRIx to go beyond the limitations of univariate analyses by studying multiple variables simultaneously. This is especially important for understanding complex systems where multiple factors interact in non-linear ways, such as the interplay between climate change, political stability, and food security. In assessing the risk of social unrest, GRIx might use multivariate methods to analyze factors like unemployment rates, income inequality, and public sentiment together. By doing so, it can uncover more complex relationships and higher-order interactions between these variables, providing a more complete picture of risk.
  • Random Forests: Random Forests is a machine learning algorithm that can handle a large set of features and identify the most important ones for prediction. For instance, when assessing the risk of a financial market crash, many variables like trading volumes, interest rates, and geopolitical events come into play. Random Forests can analyze all these together to provide a comprehensive risk assessment. When evaluating the risk of pandemics, GRIx could employ Random Forests to analyze various factors such as population density, vaccination rates, and international travel frequencies to predict the likelihood and potential impact of an outbreak.
  • Support Vector Machines (SVM): Support Vector Machines are effective for both classification and regression tasks in high-dimensional spaces. In the complex world of global risks, where numerous variables can affect the outcome, SVMs can be particularly useful. Suppose GRIx wants to classify countries based on their susceptibility to cyber threats. Using an SVM algorithm, it could take into account factors like a country’s technological infrastructure, its cybersecurity policies, and historical data on cyber attacks to accurately categorize risk levels.
  • Natural Language Processing (NLP): Natural Language Processing allows GRIx to analyze unstructured textual data like news articles, social media feeds, and expert reports. This is vital for understanding public sentiment, tracking the spread of misinformation, or identifying emerging trends and threats that haven’t been quantified yet. In monitoring the risk of political instability, GRIx could use NLP to analyze news articles and social media posts to gauge public sentiment towards a government or policy. By tracking keywords, phrases, or topics that are trending, GRIx can offer real-time insights into the factors that may contribute to political upheaval.

Instantaneous Analysis and System Agility

The GRIx framework is engineered for agility, aiming to provide up-to-the-minute risk assessments. By harnessing data from IoT sensors and employing edge computing, GRIx ensures immediate data collection and preliminary analysis. It applies time-series analytics and state-space models to continually monitor how risk elements evolve over time. Furthermore, GRIx integrates Reinforcement Learning (RL) algorithms to dynamically refine its risk-assessment methodologies based on real-world outcomes, thereby operationalizing the principles of dynamic systems theory.

  • IoT Sensors: Internet of Things (IoT) sensors serve as the eyes and ears of the GRIx system in the real world. These sensors collect data ranging from temperature and humidity to more complex variables like air quality or radiation levels. This real-time data allows for up-to-date risk assessments. In the context of assessing environmental risks, GRIx could deploy IoT sensors in a forest to monitor moisture levels, temperature, and wind speed. These data would be vital in real-time wildfire risk assessment.
  • Edge Computing: Edge computing can complement the IoT infrastructure in GRIx by processing data near its source. This reduces the latency and bandwidth use that would result from sending all data to a centralized server, allowing for quicker response times in risk identification and management. Suppose GRIx is monitoring an industrial plant for chemical leak risks. Edge computing devices onsite could process sensor data in real-time to detect irregularities. Immediate local action could then be taken even before the data reaches a central server for deeper analysis.
  • Time-Series Analysis: Time-series analysis can be employed in GRIx to study how certain risk indicators evolve over time. By examining data sequentially, GRIx can identify trends, seasonal patterns, or sudden spikes that may signify increased risk. In monitoring financial market stability, GRIx could use time-series analysis to track stock prices, trading volumes, and interest rates. Identifying unusual patterns in these time-ordered data points could serve as an early warning sign of market instability.
  • State-Space Models: State-Space Models allow GRIx to understand how a system or risk factor evolves over time while considering its current “state” and how it reacts to various inputs or changes. This is especially valuable for complex systems where the interactions between variables are not straightforward. When assessing the risk of a pandemic, a State-Space Model could be used to track various states like ‘infection rates,’ ‘vaccination rates,’ and ‘public compliance with health measures,’ to predict future states of the pandemic.
  • Reinforcement Learning (RL): Reinforcement Learning (RL) in GRIx could be employed to optimize decision-making strategies in complex and dynamic risk environments. An RL algorithm learns from both successful and unsuccessful outcomes, refining its strategies over time to maximize some notion of cumulative reward. Suppose GRIx is used to manage cybersecurity risks. An RL algorithm could learn from previous cyberattacks and successful defenses to adapt and improve the system’s future responses to similar threats.
  • Dynamic Systems Theory: Dynamic Systems Theory provides GRIx with the conceptual framework to understand how complex systems—like ecological systems, economies, or societies—change over time. By understanding the dynamics, GRIx can make more accurate risk assessments and more effective interventions. In the context of climate change risk, Dynamic Systems Theory would allow GRIx to consider how factors like CO2 levels, global temperatures, and sea ice extent interact in a complex system, and how interventions in one area might affect the entire system.

Ethical Integrity and Inclusive Risk Management

Ethical considerations are deeply ingrained in the DNA of GRIx. The platform utilizes fairness-aware algorithms to counteract and minimize societal biases that could be perpetuated through risk assessments. Ethical frameworks, including both deontological and utilitarian principles, are integrated to guide morally sound decision-making processes. To ensure representational equity, GRIx adopts stratified sampling techniques that actively include marginalized or under-represented communities in its data gathering.

  • Fairness-Aware Algorithms: Fairness-aware algorithms in GRIx are designed to identify and minimize systemic biases that could otherwise influence risk assessments. These algorithms ensure that the risk evaluation process does not disproportionately affect certain communities or individuals based on factors such as ethnicity, gender, or socioeconomic status. Imagine a scenario where GRIx is assessing community vulnerability to natural disasters. A fairness-aware algorithm would ensure that assessments and subsequent resource allocations do not systematically disadvantage particular neighborhoods based on factors like income level or ethnic composition.
  • Deontological Principles: Incorporating deontological principles into GRIx ensures that the framework adheres to ethical norms that focus on the intrinsic rightness or wrongness of actions. This can serve as a safeguard against actions that may achieve beneficial outcomes but do so through ethically questionable means. Suppose GRIx is used for healthcare resource allocation during a pandemic. A deontological approach might ensure that all individuals have equal access to care, irrespective of their predicted medical outcome, upholding the principle that all human life is valuable.
  • Utilitarian Principles: Utilitarian principles would guide GRIx’s decision-making processes by evaluating the potential consequences of different actions. These principles seek to maximize overall welfare, even if it involves difficult trade-offs. In a climate change mitigation scenario, a utilitarian approach would involve evaluating various strategies like carbon taxing, renewable energy investment, and conservation efforts to find the combination that achieves the greatest reduction in overall global emissions and long-term climate impact.
  • Stratified Sampling: Stratified sampling ensures that GRIx’s risk assessments are based on data that accurately represents diverse populations. By dividing the population into distinct subgroups based on specific characteristics (like age, income, geography, etc.), and then sampling from each of these strata, GRIx can produce more balanced and equitable assessments. Let’s consider a public health risk assessment for an infectious disease. Stratified sampling would involve collecting data from various demographic groups (e.g., different age groups, ethnic communities, urban and rural areas, etc.) to make sure that the resulting risk profile genuinely reflects the vulnerability and exposure across the entire population.

Civic Engagement and Institutional Accountability

GRIx is meticulously designed to be an open and participatory framework, actively encouraging public participation. It utilizes mechanisms like crowdsourcing and the Delphi method to amass expert opinions and to tap into collective wisdom. Additionally, GRIx adopts Explainable AI (XAI) approaches to make its computational algorithms and decision-making processes transparent, accessible, and understandable to the general public, thus strengthening institutional accountability and trust.

  • Crowdsourcing: Crowdsourcing within GRIx serves as a mechanism for public input and scrutiny. It allows for the collection of data, opinions, and situational awareness from a large, diverse group of people, which can enrich risk assessments and proposed mitigation strategies. Imagine GRIx is assessing the risk of urban flooding. By employing crowdsourcing, the framework can gather real-time data from residents who can report water levels, blocked drains, or other risk factors. This data complements official channels and provides a more comprehensive understanding of the situation on the ground.
  • Delphi Methods: The Delphi Method is utilized in GRIx to tap into the collective expertise of various subject-matter experts. This structured technique involves multiple rounds of questionnaires and reviews, allowing experts to refine their opinions based on the aggregated knowledge of the group. In determining the geopolitical risks associated with a particular issue, GRIx might employ the Delphi Method to solicit opinions from geopolitical analysts, economists, and military experts. After several rounds of questioning and sharing anonymized responses, a more refined and consensus-driven assessment of the risk can be achieved.
  • Explainable AI (XAI): Explainable AI techniques are integral to GRIx to ensure that its risk assessments and recommendations are not just accurate but also understandable and accountable to decision-makers and the public. XAI techniques aim to break down the complexity of machine learning models into interpretable components, offering insights into how specific conclusions were reached. Let’s consider GRIx employing a complex neural network for predicting cybersecurity threats. With Explainable AI, the framework can detail how the model arrived at a specific risk assessment. For instance, it can show the weight it gave to recent data breaches, irregular network traffic, or unpatched software vulnerabilities, making the model’s decision-making process transparent and understandable.

In alignment with the urgent requirements for a more robust, agile, ethical, and community-engaged approach to global risk management, the objectives of GRIx are both timely and transformative. By amalgamating sophisticated techniques from data science, cognitive science, and risk sciences, GRIx aspires to pioneer a new era in how we conceptualize, understand, and mitigate risks in a world that is both extraordinarily complex and rapidly evolving.

Theoretical Foundations

The Evolution from Homo Economicus to Machina Economicus

The classical economic model known as Homo Economicus, which postulates that human agents act rationally and in their own self-interest, is undergoing a significant transformation. It’s giving way to a more complex paradigm called Machina Economicus, where machine agents, driven by advanced AI and machine learning algorithms, are active participants in economic and decision-making frameworks. This shift requires that traditional risk assessment models be retooled to account for machine agents capable of processing data and making decisions at a speed and scale humans cannot match. To facilitate this, GRIx uses Game Theory and Multi-Agent Systems to model interactions between human and machine actors in complex, dynamic risk environments.

  • Homo Economicus: A simplified economic model that describes humans as consistently rational, self-interested beings. In the GRIx framework, this model is expanded to account for the complex, multifaceted nature of human decision-making, especially in the context of global risks.
  • Machina Economicus: This is the next evolution of the economic agent, incorporating machine-based entities alongside humans. In GRIx, Machina Economicus is relevant because machine agents often have access to broader data sets and can process them more rapidly, thus influencing economic and risk-related decisions.
  • Game Theory: This is a branch of mathematics that deals with decision-making among multiple interacting agents. In the context of GRIx, Game Theory is used to model how both human and machine agents might respond to various global risks, allowing for more dynamic and nuanced risk assessment.
  • Multi-Agent Systems: These are systems in which multiple entities, whether human or machine, interact with each other. For GRIx, understanding these systems is crucial for modeling complex interactions in risk scenarios, especially where machine agents are involved.

Integration of Large Language Models (LLMs), AI, and IoT Technologies

GRIx employs cutting-edge Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 to analyze and generate text, thereby enabling a more sophisticated scrutiny of textual data like news articles, academic papers, and social media feeds. Additionally, AI techniques such as neural networks and deep learning facilitate pattern recognition, anomaly detection, and predictive analytics. The framework also utilizes the Internet of Things (IoT) to source real-time data, offering dynamic risk assessments. To create a unified, comprehensive view of global risks, these technologies are synthesized using data fusion methods and Bayesian networks.

  • Large Language Models (LLMs): These are highly sophisticated machine learning models trained on extensive datasets for understanding and generating text. In GRIx, LLMs like GPT-4 are used for advanced textual analysis, enhancing the framework’s ability to discern emerging trends and public sentiments related to global risks.
  • Neural Networks: These algorithms emulate the human brain’s interconnected neuron structure to recognize complex patterns. Within GRIx, neural networks are employed for intricate tasks such as anomaly detection in financial markets or climate data analysis.
  • Deep Learning: A specialized subset of machine learning, deep learning mimics the functioning of the human brain to interpret multiple layers of abstraction in data. For GRIx, this might involve deep learning algorithms for speech recognition in monitoring public sentiment or for image recognition in assessing infrastructure risks.
  • Data Fusion: This involves the integration of multiple types and sources of data to provide a more accurate and comprehensive view. In GRIx, data from IoT sensors, textual analysis by LLMs, and expert opinions may be fused to offer a holistic risk assessment.
  • Bayesian Networks: These are probabilistic models that depict a set of variables and their conditional dependencies. In GRIx, Bayesian networks can be used to model the complex interdependencies between various risk factors, helping to predict the probability of different risk events occurring.

Ethical Imperatives and Governance Structures

At the heart of GRIx’s architecture are ethical considerations framed by principles like distributive justice, informed consent, and transparency. The framework employs algorithmic fairness to avoid perpetuating societal biases and includes robust governance protocols. These protocols feature elements of participatory governance and ethical oversight, and they are built to be compliant with regulatory standards such as the GDPR.

  • Distributive Justice: This refers to the equitable distribution of resources and opportunities. In GRIx, algorithmic methods are designed to ensure that risk assessments and interventions are fair and equitable across different populations.
  • Informed Consent: This principle ensures that participants in a study or system are fully aware of the potential risks and rewards. For GRIx, this might relate to the ethical collection and use of personal data for risk assessments.
  • Algorithmic Fairness: This involves the development of algorithms that provide equal opportunities and outcomes for all individuals, regardless of their background. GRIx places a strong emphasis on ensuring that its algorithms are free from biases that could disadvantage particular groups.
  • Participatory Governance: This governance model actively involves stakeholders at various levels in decision-making processes. In the case of GRIx, this may involve public participation in shaping risk assessment methodologies or governance policies.
  • GDPR: Standing for General Data Protection Regulation, this EU regulation governs data protection and privacy. GRIx is engineered to comply with GDPR, safeguarding individual privacy and data rights.

GRIx is built on a foundation of advanced computational methods, ethical principles, and robust governance protocols. The framework aims to set a new benchmark in our capacity to understand, assess, and mitigate the multifaceted risks in a world that is increasingly being shaped by both human and machine agents.

Features

Artificial Intelligece (AI)/ Machine learning (ML)

GRIx utilizes state-of-the-art machine learning and AI technologies to perform predictive analytics. By harnessing the power of algorithms such as decision trees, neural networks, and ensemble methods, the framework can anticipate future risks with a higher degree of accuracy. For example, stochastic modeling techniques are employed to predict geopolitical risks like civil unrest, while Monte Carlo simulations may be used to assess financial market volatilities.

  • Decision Trees: These are tree-like graphs that model decisions and their possible consequences. In GRIx, decision trees may be used to evaluate the potential impacts of natural disasters based on various environmental variables.
  • Ensemble Methods: These techniques combine predictions from multiple machine learning algorithms to produce a more robust model. For instance, ensemble methods in GRIx could combine climate models and economic indicators to predict the likelihood of food shortages in specific regions.
  • Stochastic Modeling: This modeling includes elements of randomness to account for uncertainty and unpredictability in risk scenarios. In GRIx, stochastic models might be used to predict the spread of infectious diseases considering variables like human mobility and vaccination rates.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: This is a statistical technique that uses repeated random sampling to model complex systems. Within GRIx, Monte Carlo simulations could simulate thousands of possible economic outcomes based on current market conditions to predict future market risks.

Internet of things (IoT)

GRIx incorporates Internet of Things (IoT) sensors to gather real-time data. These sensors can track a multitude of factors, from environmental variables like air quality to technological parameters like network latency, to provide immediate, actionable insights. For example, IoT sensors placed in industrial facilities could monitor for hazardous materials leaks, with the data being fed into GRIx for immediate risk assessment.

  • IoT Sensors: These are smart devices capable of collecting data from their environment and transmitting it to a centralized system. In the context of GRIx, such sensors might be deployed in urban areas to monitor air quality or traffic conditions.
  • Analytics Engine: This is the computational core of GRIx that processes, analyzes, and interprets the data collected. It uses machine learning algorithms and statistical methods to make sense of the vast amount of information fed into it.

The Global Risks Index (GRIx) framework is designed to be a versatile, robust, and comprehensive solution for assessing and managing various types of risks, from environmental hazards to cybersecurity threats. One of the key technologies that empower GRIx to achieve this mission is the Internet of Things (IoT). IoT’s capability to provide real-time data collection and monitoring is a critical asset in GRIx’s multi-dimensional risk assessment strategy.

Role of IoT in GRIx: In the GRIx framework, IoT serves as the frontline in data collection, providing a continuous, real-time flow of information that forms the basis for dynamic risk assessment. The variety of sensors can be tailored to the specific needs of the risk categories being evaluated:

  1. Environmental Risks: IoT sensors can monitor air and water quality, radiation levels, and other ecological indicators. These metrics are invaluable for assessing risks related to pollution, climate change, and natural disasters.
  2. Technological Risks: Sensors monitor key parameters in systems and networks, such as latency, data throughput, and unauthorized access attempts. This data is crucial for assessing the security and integrity of critical infrastructure.
  3. Socio-Economic Risks: In smart cities, IoT can also help in monitoring social parameters like crowd density, traffic flow, and even public sentiment, assisting in assessing risks like social unrest or economic downturns.

Integration with Advanced Connectivity: GRIx leverages advanced networking technologies like LPWAN, LoRaWAN, and future 5G/6G infrastructures to ensure seamless and secure data transmission from IoT devices to the central analytics engine. These technologies are vital for:

  • Scalability: They enable GRIx to handle vast arrays of interconnected sensors, making it viable for large-scale deployments such as city-wide or even nation-wide risk assessment.
  • Efficiency: Technologies like LPWAN offer energy-efficient ways to transmit data over long distances, making it sustainable and cost-effective.
  • Latency: Advanced networking protocols ensure that data is transferred in near-real-time, allowing for immediate risk assessments and prompt decision-making.

Real-world Examples

  1. Disaster Response: Imagine a coastal city equipped with IoT sensors monitoring sea levels and weather conditions. These sensors could provide immediate data to GRIx when a tsunami or storm is imminent, enabling timely evacuation orders.
  2. Industrial Safeguards: In a factory setting, sensors could detect hazardous gas leaks, extreme temperatures, or machinery malfunctions. GRIx would then instantly assess the level of risk and recommend corrective actions, potentially preventing accidents or catastrophic events.
  3. Smart Health Monitoring: In the context of a pandemic, IoT sensors could monitor temperature and foot traffic in public areas. GRIx could analyze this data to assess the risk of disease spread and recommend preventive measures like lockdowns or social distancing protocols.

Analytics Engine and IoT Data

The GRIx analytics engine is the cornerstone that takes the raw data from IoT sensors and turns it into actionable insights. Utilizing machine learning algorithms, the analytics engine can recognize patterns, predict future scenarios, and flag anomalies, thereby playing a pivotal role in risk assessment and mitigation strategies. IoT is not just an add-on but an integral component of the GRIx framework, deeply embedded into its architecture and operational protocols. Its inclusion is critical for achieving the real-time, dynamic, and multi-faceted risk assessments that are the hallmark of GRIx.

Zero-Trust Architecture for Data Security

Recognizing that cybersecurity threats can arise from any point in a network, GRIx employs a zero-trust architecture. This approach requires rigorous verification of each entity attempting to access the system, thereby bolstering data security. For example, if an employee tries to access sensitive risk assessment reports, they must go through multiple layers of authentication, irrespective of their physical location.

In an era where cyber threats are increasingly sophisticated and pervasive, safeguarding sensitive data has never been more critical. The Global Risks Index (GRIx) takes a pioneering approach by adopting advanced cybersecurity frameworks, combining zero-trust architecture with zero-knowledge proof protocols. This dual-layered security mechanism makes GRIx a beacon of cybersecurity excellence in the landscape of risk assessment and management.

Zero-Trust Architecture: The zero-trust model is built on the premise that trust should never be assumed; it must be earned and continuously verified. This architecture is particularly pertinent for a comprehensive risk assessment tool like GRIx, which gathers and processes a wide variety of data that may have implications for national security, public health, and economic stability. How Zero-Trust Architecture is Implemented in GRIx:

  1. Dynamic Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Whether it’s an internal employee or a third-party consultant, anyone attempting to access GRIx’s vast data reserves must undergo dynamic MFA. This multi-step verification may include password challenges, biometric scans, and secure tokens.
  2. Role-Based Access Control: Within GRIx, permissions are meticulously allocated based on the ‘least privilege’ principle. That is, individuals are granted just enough access to perform their assigned tasks and no more. For example, while a systems administrator might have broad access, a junior analyst would have significantly restricted capabilities.
  3. Real-Time Security Monitoring and Adaptive Controls: Zero-trust architecture in GRIx goes beyond initial access. Its analytics engine employs real-time monitoring to scan for anomalies in network traffic and user behavior, allowing for immediate action if a threat is detected.

Let’s consider a government agency using GRIx to evaluate risks related to critical infrastructure, like power grids. With a zero-trust model, even high-level officials would need to go through rigorous authentication processes to access or modify any risk parameters, thereby providing a robust line of defense against internal and external threats.

Zero-Knowledge Proof Protocols: To provide an additional layer of security, GRIx integrates zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs). ZKPs are cryptographic methods that allow one party to prove the veracity of a claim without revealing the underlying data. How Zero-Knowledge Proof is Applied in GRIx:

  1. Data Masking and Anonymization: When collecting sensitive data, ZKPs are used to confirm the data’s validity without exposing its content. This is crucial in cases involving personally identifiable information or classified data, ensuring that GRIx adheres to stringent data protection laws.
  2. Query Execution on Encrypted Data: ZKP technology allows GRIx to perform calculations and queries on encrypted datasets without ever needing to decrypt the data. This means that even if a cyber-attack were successful, the assailants would find only encrypted, unusable data.

Imagine a pharmaceutical company utilizing GRIx to assess the risks of a new drug development project. Patient data and intellectual property are highly sensitive. Zero-knowledge proof protocols enable the company to validate the accuracy of the clinical trial data without compromising participant confidentiality or proprietary information.

Synergizing Zero-Trust and Zero-Knowledge for Optimal Security: The integration of zero-trust architecture and zero-knowledge proof protocols produces a highly secure environment that addresses multiple facets of cybersecurity:

  1. Fortified Data Security: By incorporating zero-trust with zero-knowledge protocols, GRIx minimizes the risks associated with data breaches and unauthorized access.
  2. Heightened Privacy Assurance: The double-layered security assures stakeholders that sensitive information will remain confidential and anonymous.
  3. Global Compliance and Scalability: This security framework is designed to meet global standards like GDPR for data protection, making GRIx compatible and scalable across international markets and regulatory environments.

The GRIx platform sets a new industry standard by fusing zero-trust and zero-knowledge security mechanisms. This powerful combination ensures that every data point, user, and transaction is subjected to rigorous verification and encryption, offering a level of security and privacy that is unparalleled in the field of global risk assessment.

Open-Source Code and Methodologies

In line with open science principles, GRIx provides open-source code and methodologies. This promotes an inclusive and collaborative environment where experts from diverse fields can contribute to the framework’s evolution. For example, academic researchers could tweak the existing algorithms to test new theories of risk assessment, sharing their findings and code for others to use and build upon.

The Open Ethos of GRIx

In an era characterized by rapid technological changes and complex global challenges, collaborative innovation is more essential than ever. The Global Risks Index (GRIx) embraces this collaborative spirit at its core, underpinned by its commitment to open source and open science principles. By weaving openness into the fabric of its operational and philosophical ethos, GRIx not only ensures transparency but also encourages contributions from diverse communities for the betterment of risk assessment methodologies.

Open-Source Code: The Backbone of Collaborative Innovation

The idea behind open-source code is simple but powerful: when you make source code freely available for modification and distribution, you unleash collective creativity. This benefits not only GRIx but also the broader community of scientists, engineers, and policymakers working on global risk assessment. How GRIx Implements Open-Source Principles:

  1. Public Repositories: All of GRIx’s algorithms and methodologies are stored in public code repositories, allowing anyone to fork, modify, and improve upon them.
  2. Contribution Guidelines: To streamline the collaborative process, GRIx provides detailed documentation and contribution guidelines, ensuring that additions and modifications meet high standards of quality and relevance.
  3. Community Reviews: Proposed changes to GRIx’s codebase are subject to community review, providing layers of expert scrutiny that improve the robustness of the platform.

Consider a team of climate scientists who specialize in sea-level rise. They could take GRIx’s existing algorithms, modify them to incorporate new climate models, and then share these improved models back with the GRIx community. This benefits everyone by producing more accurate risk assessments for coastal regions.

Open Science: Broadening the Horizons of Knowledge and Participation

Open science aims to democratize knowledge, making scientific data, research findings, and methodologies accessible to all. GRIx takes this commitment seriously, offering not just open-source code but also open data and open-access research publications whenever possible. How GRIx Implements Open Science:

  1. Data Accessibility: Raw and processed datasets used by GRIx for risk assessments are made publicly available, adhering to open data principles. This allows for third-party validation and alternative analyses.
  2. Collaborative Research and Peer Review: GRIx actively participates in peer-reviewed scientific publications, allowing the wider scientific community to scrutinize and validate its methodologies.
  3. Community Engagement: The framework also hosts webinars, workshops, and public consultations, fostering an inclusive dialogue around risk management.

Imagine public health researchers interested in pandemic preparedness. They could leverage GRIx’s open data and methodologies to simulate the spread of infectious diseases, thereby contributing to the existing body of knowledge and helping shape more effective policies.

Synergies in Open Collaboration: The open-source and open science dimensions of GRIx are interdependent and mutually reinforcing:

  1. Transparency and Trust: The open nature of GRIx lends itself to greater transparency, which in turn builds trust among its users and contributors.
  2. Interdisciplinary Collaboration: By being open to contributions from a wide array of fields, GRIx benefits from interdisciplinary insights, enriching its risk assessment models.
  3. Global Reach and Scalability: The open principles ensure that GRIx is compatible with various international standards and can be adapted to localized risk landscapes.
  4. Ethical and Social Considerations: Open science principles resonate with broader ethical and social responsibilities, such as inclusivity and public engagement.

By ardently embracing open source and open science, GRIx becomes more than a risk assessment tool—it evolves into a dynamic, collaborative ecosystem. This fosters a continually improving framework that is more robust, transparent, and capable of addressing the multifaceted risks that define our interconnected world.

Transparent Algorithms and Decision-Making Processes

Transparency is a cornerstone of GRIx, realized through the adoption of Explainable AI (XAI) techniques. These methods ensure that the algorithms employed in risk assessment are not just efficient but also understandable and accountable. For instance, if GRIx identifies an increased risk of flooding in a specific area, the XAI techniques would allow it to provide understandable reasoning behind this prediction, making it more trustworthy.

A Unified Framework for Collaborative, Multi-Scale Risk Management

In a world facing an unprecedented confluence of risks—from climate change and pandemics to socio-economic disparities and geopolitical instability—a revolutionary approach to risk assessment and mitigation is essential. Merging artificial intelligence (AI) and human expertise, GRIx offers a transparent, accountable, and ethical decision-making platform built upon the pillars of shared intelligence and active inference.

Shared Intelligence

The Foundation of Collaborative Risk Management: GRIx is architected around the paradigm of shared intelligence, which fosters seamless interaction between human and AI agents. This collaborative ecosystem exchanges information and insights in real-time for comprehensive and effective risk assessment. By leveraging shared intelligence, GRIx delivers:

  • Real-Time Data Collection: Utilizing IoT sensors integrated within urban and natural landscapes, GRIx gathers real-time data on various environmental variables like air quality, feeding them into its advanced analytics engine.
  • Collaborative Decision-Making: Through dynamic role assignment, human experts and AI agents collaborate to make nuanced judgments and ethical decisions.
  • Enhanced Prediction Accuracy: The collective wisdom of human and AI agents continually refines the algorithms, ensuring that GRIx’s risk assessments become progressively more accurate.

Active Inference

A Physics-Based Approach to Intelligence: GRIx incorporates the concept of active inference, a physics-based model that sees intelligence as the accumulation of evidence to optimize an agent’s generative model of their environment. Active inference allows GRIx to:

  • Dynamic Understanding of Risk: For example, GRIx can adapt its risk assessments for wildfires in real-time, based on changing variables like wind speed and direction.
  • Proactive Measures: Beyond just notifying authorities or stakeholders, GRIx can recommend preventative actions like controlled burns to effectively mitigate risks.

AI-Human Collaboration for Resilience Building: The synergy between AI’s data-crunching capabilities and human ethical judgment is central to GRIx’s ecosystem. Mechanisms like dynamic role assignment and feedback loops ensure continuous improvement. Explainable AI serves as a ‘common language’ that facilitates dialogue and decision-making among human and AI agents.

Multi-Scale Analysis for Holistic Risk Management: GRIx is adaptable to different scales of risks, from local issues like community air quality to global crises like climate change.

  • Modular Algorithms: GRIx employs specialized algorithms that can be customized to address specific risks, such as floods in coastal areas or wildfires in forest regions.
  • Localized Customization: Local sensors and data feed into GRIx, allowing for fine-tuned, context-specific risk assessments.
  • Global Governance: By aligning with international standards, GRIx ensures its framework is both robust and universally applicable.

As we navigate through a world replete with intricate and evolving risks, frameworks like GRIx stand as beacons of hope. Through its commitment to shared intelligence, active inference, and a multi-scale approach, GRIx paves the way for a future where risk management is more resilient, transparent, and collaborative. By synergizing cutting-edge technological innovation with ethical governance, GRIx serves as a model for meeting the challenges that lie ahead, offering a blueprint for risk management in the 21st century.

Public Participation

GRIx engages the public through participatory mechanisms like consultations and surveys. This democratizes the risk assessment process, making it more comprehensive and inclusive. For example, before assessing the risk levels of a new infrastructure project, GRIx might circulate public surveys to gather local opinions and concerns, which would then be factored into the final risk assessment.

  • Community Science Programs: Community Science Programs empower everyday people to contribute to scientific research. Within the GRIx framework, this takes the form of decentralized data collection, often via IoT-enabled devices or smartphones. For example, residents in a community could be equipped with air quality sensors that feed into GRIx’s analytics engine. This local data, when combined with other data streams, helps create a more holistic environmental risk profile for the area. The advantage is twofold: it enriches GRIx’s data pool and engages the community in active participation, thereby enhancing both the quality and social acceptability of risk assessments.
  • Deliberative Polling: Deliberative Polling is designed to gauge public opinion on specific issues in an informed setting. In the context of GRIx, this method can be employed to understand public sentiment toward different kinds of risks. For instance, GRIx could initiate a digital deliberative poll focused on flood risks. Participants would be educated about the complexities and available options before casting their votes. Their feedback could be integrated into the machine learning models GRIx uses for flood risk assessment, ensuring that public opinion is considered in decision-making algorithms.
  • Open Algorithms and Public Code Review: Transparency is essential for public trust, and GRIx acknowledges this by making its algorithms and methodologies open-source. This allows for public code review, inviting experts and laypeople alike to scrutinize and improve the system. For example, a cybersecurity expert could suggest an algorithmic improvement to better handle zero-trust architecture, thereby fortifying GRIx against potential threats. By creating an open space for collaboration, GRIx democratizes risk assessment and allows for collective intelligence to refine its methods continuously.
  • Virtual Town Halls: Virtual Town Halls offer platforms for public discussion and collective decision-making. Within GRIx, these could be scheduled events where community members discuss potential risks—like an upcoming hurricane season—and propose solutions. These sessions could feed directly into GRIx’s decision-making process, allowing real people’s voices to influence machine algorithms. For example, if a community is particularly concerned about emergency evacuation routes, that data could become a parameter in GRIx’s risk assessment for natural disasters.
  • Gamification and Crowdsourcing: The use of game-like elements can stimulate public engagement in complex issues. GRIx could develop a gamified interface where users are rewarded for identifying and tagging potential risks in their community, like a suspicious abandoned vehicle that could be a security risk. This not only educates the public on risk assessment but also provides GRIx with valuable grassroots-level data. Crowdsourced insights can feed into machine learning algorithms, allowing for a more nuanced and community-informed risk assessment.
  • Decentralized Innovation Commons Ecosystem (DICE): DICE acts as a decentralized platform where stakeholders can collaboratively contribute to risk assessment and management. Governed under the quintuple helix governance model, it integrates academia, industry, government, civil society, and the public in decision-making. In GRIx, a DICE could focus on creating resilient urban landscapes. City planners, engineers, and citizens could propose, debate, and iterate solutions, with the results incorporated directly into GRIx’s analytics engine.

Crowdsourcing and Collective Intelligence

GRIx taps into the wisdom of the crowd through crowdsourcing techniques and collective intelligence methodologies. This allows the framework to gather a broader range of perspectives and insights. For instance, GRIx might use crowdsourcing to collect data on consumer behavior during a product recall, offering a more nuanced understanding of public sentiment and behavior. GRIx harnesses the collective power of diverse minds by integrating advanced crowdsourcing techniques and collective intelligence methodologies. This fusion not only amplifies the depth and breadth of insights but also ensures a more holistic understanding of complex scenarios.

Evolution of Crowdsourcing in GRIx: Crowdsourcing, traditionally seen as a tool for data collection, has evolved into a multifaceted mechanism in the GRIx framework. With the rise of decentralized platforms and the gig economy, GRIx can now tap into specialized expertise on-demand, ensuring that the right experts are consulted for specific challenges.

Collective Intelligence: Beyond Data Collection: GRIx’s approach to collective intelligence goes beyond mere aggregation. By leveraging advanced algorithms and machine learning models, the framework can identify patterns, biases, and knowledge gaps in the data collected. This ensures that the insights derived are not just comprehensive but also refined and actionable.

  • Decentralized Platforms: With the rise of blockchain technology, GRIx can ensure data integrity and transparency in crowdsourcing efforts. Decentralized platforms also allow for real-time collaboration among participants, fostering a more dynamic data collection process.
  • Gamification: To enhance engagement and participation, GRIx has started incorporating gamification elements in its crowdsourcing initiatives. This not only boosts participation rates but also ensures that participants are motivated to provide quality insights.
  • Natural Language Processing (NLP): GRIx employs advanced NLP techniques to analyze textual data from crowdsourcing efforts. This allows for sentiment analysis, topic modeling, and trend identification, offering a deeper understanding of public sentiment, especially in scenarios like product recalls.
  • Predictive Analytics: By integrating predictive analytics, GRIx can forecast potential risks or opportunities based on the data collected. This proactive approach ensures that measures can be taken well in advance, enhancing the framework’s risk mitigation capabilities.

Consider a situation where there’s a product recall. Instead of merely collecting data on consumer behavior, GRIx, with its enhanced capabilities, can predict potential market reactions, identify regions with heightened negative sentiments, and even suggest mitigation strategies based on historical data and current trends. The integration of gamification can also encourage consumers to provide feedback, ensuring a more comprehensive understanding of the situation.

GRIx’s approach to crowdsourcing and collective intelligence is not static. By continuously integrating the latest trends and innovations, the framework ensures that it remains at the forefront of risk assessment and mitigation, offering solutions that are both timely and effective.

Alignment with International Standards and Frameworks

GRIx aligns with internationally recognized standards, including ISO 31000 for risk management. This ensures that the framework’s methodologies and processes are up-to-date and universally accepted. For instance, by aligning with ISO 31000, GRIx assures stakeholders that its risk assessments are conducted following globally recognized best practices.

  1. ISO 31000: Risk Management: ISO 31000 provides a universally recognized set of guidelines for risk management. By aligning with these principles, GRIx ensures that its methodologies for identifying, assessing, and managing risks are in line with global best practices. This adds an extra layer of credibility and effectiveness, which is crucial for building trust among stakeholders.
  2. ISO 27001: Information Security Management: Given the digital age we live in, information security is of paramount importance. GRIx’s alignment with ISO 27001 guarantees that data management within the framework adheres to the highest global standards for information security. This is essential for maintaining the integrity and confidentiality of the data used in GRIx’s risk assessments.
  3. COSO Enterprise Risk Management Framework: COSO’s comprehensive approach to enterprise risk management is highly regarded globally. By incorporating COSO’s principles, GRIx ensures that it considers both the organization’s strategic objectives and its risk appetite when conducting risk assessments. This balanced approach is integral for providing actionable and insightful guidance.
  4. NIST Cybersecurity Framework: Cybersecurity is an ever-evolving concern for organizations. GRIx’s alignment with the NIST framework means that it adopts a set of robust guidelines designed to manage and mitigate cybersecurity risks effectively. This proactive focus on digital security adds resilience and reliability to the framework.
  5. Basel III Framework: Basel III offers a robust regulatory framework focusing on capital adequacy and market liquidity. By adhering to this framework, GRIx demonstrates its commitment to upholding global banking standards, which is particularly relevant for stakeholders in the financial sector.
  6. FAIR Data Principles: Data is often termed ‘the new oil,’ and GRIx’s adoption of FAIR Data Principles ensures that this valuable resource is managed effectively. By making data Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable, GRIx enhances the utility and value of the information used in its risk assessments.
  7. Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction: With the rising frequency and impact of natural disasters, GRIx’s alignment with the Sendai Framework equips it to deal comprehensively with disaster-related risks. This ensures that both immediate and long-term impacts are taken into account, thereby offering a holistic approach to disaster risk management.
  8. Greenhouse Gas Protocol (GHG Protocol) and UNFCCC: Climate change is a global issue, and GRIx’s alignment with these environmental standards ensures that it is at the forefront of managing related risks. This demonstrates GRIx’s commitment to sustainability and positions it as a leader in environmental risk assessment.
  9. UN Global Compact and 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development: By aligning with these frameworks, GRIx underlines its commitment to ethical governance and corporate responsibility. This not only adds a moral dimension to its risk assessments but also ensures alignment with globally recognized sustainable development goals.
  10. Global Disaster Alert and Coordination System (GDACS) and International Disaster Emergency Service (IDES): GDACS and IDES offer real-time alerts and a humanitarian perspective on global emergencies. By incorporating these services, GRIx enhances its capabilities in disaster response and recovery, making it more agile and responsive to real-world crises.

These alignments ensure that GRIx remains a comprehensive, reliable, and universally accepted framework for risk, disaster, and crisis management. Each adds specific layers of depth and credibility to GRIx’s overall offering and instills confidence across a broad array of stakeholders.

Mechanisms for International Cooperation and Governance

GRIx includes provisions for international cooperation, facilitated through mechanisms like data-sharing agreements and collaborative research initiatives. This promotes a globally coordinated approach to risk management. For example, GRIx might collaborate with European agencies to share data on climate risks, thereby benefiting from pooled resources and expertise.

  • Data-Sharing Agreements: GRIx establishes data-sharing agreements with international agencies that meticulously define the terms and conditions for the exchange of critical information. For instance, GRIx may engage in an agreement with the World Health Organization to share data on the prevalence of infectious diseases in specific regions. These agreements cover what type of data will be shared, the manner in which it will be used, and stringent protocols for ensuring data security and privacy compliance. This enables both GRIx and its international partners to fortify their databases, providing richer context and greater reliability for predictive modeling and risk assessment.
  • Collaborative Research and Development Projects: GRIx embarks on collaborative R&D projects with international partners, bringing together complementary skills and resources. For example, GRIx could partner with the European Space Agency to develop satellite-based technologies that can monitor and predict natural disasters. Such joint initiatives aim to innovate new methodologies or technologies that advance the field of risk assessment and management, pushing the boundaries of what is currently possible and improving global resilience.
  • Multi-Stakeholder Consultations: Through structured dialogues involving a diverse set of stakeholders, GRIx seeks to capture a 360-degree view of risk landscapes and mitigation options. An example could be a consultation on cyber-risk that includes GRIx, Interpol, cybersecurity firms, and NGOs specializing in digital rights. Each stakeholder brings specialized knowledge and insights that, when pooled together, can contribute to a more comprehensive and effective risk management strategy.
  • Strategic Partnerships: GRIx often forms long-term strategic alliances with agencies and organizations globally. For example, it may forge a partnership with European agencies like the European Environment Agency to continuously share insights and best practices in climate risk assessment. These partnerships are not just transactional but involve deep cooperation, facilitating an ongoing exchange of knowledge and leveraging collective intelligence for more effective risk management.
  • Frameworks for Ongoing Communication and Joint Oversight: To effectively manage its international collaborations, GRIx adopts governance frameworks that specify mechanisms for continuous communication and joint oversight. These frameworks might include bi-annual virtual summits with partner agencies, regular status updates, and collaborative crisis simulation exercises to ensure preparedness and effective response strategies.
  • Co-Developed Risk Management Models or Early-Warning Systems: In collaboration with its international partners, GRIx often undertakes the co-development of specialized risk management models or early-warning systems. For instance, GRIx and the Japan Meteorological Agency could collaborate to develop a state-of-the-art tsunami early-warning system that uses machine learning algorithms to analyze seismic data in real-time. Such co-developed tools aim to provide actionable insights or early warnings, thus enabling quicker and more effective responses to various types of risks.

Through these multifaceted approaches, GRIx not only augments its risk management capabilities but also contributes significantly to global risk resilience. Each mechanism for international cooperation serves as a conduit for the flow of ideas, resources, and solutions, amplifying the effectiveness of GRIx’s efforts.

Multilateral Partnerships for Global Risk Mitigation

In a world fraught with complexity and uncertainty, the Global Risks Index (GRIx) is carving out a niche as an adaptable and comprehensive tool for assessing and managing an array of risks. One of the defining features of GRIx is its willingness to build networks through multilateral partnerships, which involve three or more parties from different countries. GRIx has already initiated collaborations with entities like the United Nations to undertake exhaustive risk assessments on global concerns, from climate change to human trafficking. These multilateral partnerships enable resource sharing and strategy alignment at a global scale, enriching GRIx’s database and insights for worldwide risk mitigation.

Scalability is another cornerstone of the GRIx infrastructure. As crises arise and recede, the need for rapid data processing becomes imperative. For instance, in the aftermath of a significant natural disaster, GRIx has the capacity to scale its resources seamlessly, processing a deluge of real-time data for immediate risk assessment and response coordination. This scalable infrastructure ensures that the system remains agile, accommodating ever-increasing data volumes and complex risk scenarios.

Not all risks are universal, and GRIx acknowledges this through its modular design. Organizations can customize the framework by adding or subtracting modules without affecting its core functionality. A healthcare provider, for example, could integrate a module specialized in patient data security. This modular approach allows GRIx to cater to the unique risk profiles of diverse sectors while maintaining its broader applicability.

In a rapidly evolving landscape of global risks, static models can quickly become obsolete. GRIx addresses this by incorporating self-updating algorithms that constantly refine their predictions based on new data. If novel forms of cyber threats are identified, the algorithms recalibrate themselves to include these new variables in future assessments. This makes GRIx dynamic and responsive to the emerging contours of risk.

Finally, GRIx places a high value on the insights of its user community. Built-in feedback loops collect user experiences and suggestions, providing invaluable data for ongoing refinements. If a segment of users report that a feature on the risk dashboard is not intuitive, GRIx takes this feedback to heart, optimizing that feature in subsequent updates. This creates a cycle of continuous improvement, ensuring the platform remains responsive to its users’ needs.

By ingeniously blending features like multilateral partnerships, scalable infrastructure, modular design, self-updating algorithms, and user feedback loops, GRIx has positioned itself as an ever-evolving framework for comprehensive risk assessment and management. With these capabilities, GRIx aims not just to respond to the global risk landscape but to proactively shape a more secure and resilient future.

Was this article helpful?
Dislike 0 0 of 0 found this article helpful.
Views: 36

Continue reading

Next: Global Risks Index (GRIx): Methodology
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *

Have questions?